I love the ingredients in this mascara! The black tea color is nice and dark like I wanted. I like how easily the mascara comes off at the end of the day, it makes it so much gentler on my eyelashes. The minor things I dislike are that it does take longer to dry than I'm used to, the brush holds a lot of mascara so (especially brand new) I have to be very careful applying because my lashes clump together, and the price is a bit high in my opinion. The biggest dislike, what I am still trying to get used to, is that it is not waterproof or even water resistant. When my eyes tear up from yawning I have to be careful not to smear the mascara, and sometimes at the end of the day I have dark smudges under my eyes. But, it does come off easily unlike waterproof mascara. Overall I am happy with my purchase, and it makes me feel better knowing there are pure natural ingredients.