(2 pack) Mainstays 14-Cube Ice Cube Tray with Removable Lid and Storage Bin, White

While these seem at first to be well made, there are issues. I find the lids to be impractical for stacking the trays because they are smooth and slippery. Without the lids, the trays can't be stacked in the freezer because they nest together perfectly-- forcing the water out of the bottom tray.

Every time I empty the ice from these trays I feel like the plastic is going to break. Plastic is very very thin and just feels like it won't last long. It is pretty cool having a cover for stacking and not spilling the water as you carry it back to the freezer. When I need more I will buy a better quality Ice Cube tray. I bought this because it was the cheapest.

I like that these nest/stack very nicely, so great for storage when not in use. The lid is nice for keeping in the freezer to keep odors out and prevent spills. I did not find it easy to fill through the hole in the lid, which I was hoping would be the case. Once frozen the lid isn't very easy to remove, and the trays don't release the ice easily. You have to REALLY twist them a lot to get the ice out, it usually takes several tries.

This is the most ridiculous ice tray I've ever seen! Cover is ridiculous and has a hole for filling tray but it's useless; had to use a bottle opener to get the cover off so I could fill it! Unfortunately, the tray is not pliable so it's virtually impossible to get the frozen ice out

I prefer covered ice cube trays as it really helps reduce the absorption of food smells in the ice. These make a larger ice cube than the others I had been using and slide out intact which is a big plus over my prior ones. I recommend these if you want to make your own ice cubes.

I bought these for 2 reasons. One was so my ice would be covered in the freezer and not take on any smells that might be in the freezer. Second was so I would've spill the watet when I filled them and put in the freezer. It has successfully done both of these needs BUT...the lid is absolutely horrible trying to get off to get the ice. ALSO breaking the ice out is HORRENDOUS!!! I will spend almost 5 minutes sometimes twisting and beating the bottom trying to get ice cubes. The design is severely flawed. I wish I would have purchased another kind 😞

We fill our trays from our Culligan water dispenser, the holes in the lids do not line up, this is a problem. However I full them with a pitcher or a cup and works perfectly 🥰 I love the lids so you can get an entire tray with all full ice cubes, don't spill inside the freezer and they are sturdy. Very pleased

The lid doesn't stay well. Besides that, one of the trays is hard to get the ice out of. It stinks to the tray and has to bust out, leaving ice shards in the tray. It is an odd thing, but I've noticed it since day 1. After a few months, that tray broke.

Makes perfect cubes, Easy empty - just twist the tray and ice cubes tumble out. The removable lid is a great feature, but, the lids are thin... they could be a little thicker. The lids make it easy to refill and easy to stack them in the freezer.

Flimsy construction, twists when filled and overflows on the way to the freezer. The cover and its opening's purpose are unknown.;they make filling more difficult obscuring contents leading to overfilling. Attached it does not make handling a water-filled tray any easier because it doesn't prevent leakage . it would have been better if they took the plastic of the cover and added it to the tray making the tray directly stackable and more rigid.