(2 pack) Pretty Smart Make Yourself at Home Matte Liquid Eyeliner, Matte Black, 0.02 fl oz.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This eyeliner is really great! It came well packaged, so there was no chance of it getting damaged or bouncing around, which I appreciated. One of the best things about it is that it's vegan. It has no smell and glides on smoothly, and honestly it feels good knowing I'm using safe and cruelty free ingredients, especially since it's on my face all day. It's not completely waterproof, though, which I actually didn't mind. I cried a couple of times while wearing it, and there was a little smudging, but it was easy to touch up. The plus side of it not being super waterproof is that it comes off so easily. One makeup wipe was all I needed, no scrubbing or effort required. Other than the smudging when I cried, it held up really well for about 8 hours. I even have pretty oily eyelids, and it didn't budge, which I wasn't expecting due to my regular oil buildup. Overall, I really like this eyeliner. It's easy to use, easy to take off, and works well for daily wear. I'll definitely keep using it!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I like this eyeliner because the brush it great and it's more of a matte finish which looks so pretty and is great for fancier designs! I wish the eyeliner lasted longer though, the pen dried out quickly.

Not sure if it's breviary of it being vegan (never have purchased vegan makeup before) but it is super dry. You have to do many strokes to get somewhat of bold line. Let it sit to where the liquid could flow to the tip but that did nothing… idk if it's me or the makeup lol

I opened the product to try, and no black would come out. I thought it may be dried out as I tried everything I could to get to work. I asked for a refund, but I threw away packaging. Im pretty frustrated because now im stuck with a product that doesn't work, and I technically can't take back for a refund.

very watery and not very pigmented colorwise. and the bown was non existent. store wouldn't give me refund for obviously old dri3d up makeup. avoid it,its not worth it

I received this twice, once in brown and once in black. both items were so dried out that after multiple efforts I could not get them to show up on my eyelids

I still need to return this item. No ink is coming out , even after shaking it (tried multiple times in different temperatures) .

Came very dry, and goes on dull. Waste of money.

The equivalent to dirty paint water. Not even enough pigment to make wearable.

DO NOT PURCHASE I REPEAT DO NOT PURCHASE DRIED OUT AND DOSENT WORK