Almay Conditioning Liquid Liner, Precision Felt Tip Eyeliner, Waterproof, Cruelty-Free Makeup, 30 Navy

Goes on smoothly (even on my not-so- youthful eyelids). For me it is the perfect color. Stays unsmudged for hours and hoirs

Better tip, it's a little finer than my previous purchase two years ago. I like it. Although the formula for his time it itches my eye lids and it's a little harder to take off.

I bought this product a year ago and I was amazing. My boyfriend and I used it as makeup for Halloween (unfortunately we forgot to take pictures) it was comfortable and did not budge AT ALL. I have sensitive and oily eyes and this is one of the best eyeliners I have ever used.

Love the Navy blue liner! Goes on smooth

I have used Almay eyeliners for years. This new item is GREAT. I creates slick thin lines if you need them.

easy to use and non smudge. Anxious to see how long it lasts

I do like the color, it does go on smoothly, however , it's the waterproof feature that is not accurate as it actually wipes off pretty easily

I've loved the brown liquid eyeliner for years but recently, it's really difficult to get it on my lower lid without it smudging and in a fine line. Never used to have this problem. Also, the brown seems way darker than it used to be and that is causing me to look for other brands.

Every time I used this product it burned my skin and made my eyes water. Turns out I inherited my family's pineapple allergy and this eyeliner accelerated its development.

I bought this mainly because it says it's waterproof, but it is not waterproof. Very disappointing. Won't be buying again.