Almay Intense i-Color Gel Smooth Liner, Charcoal (For Hazel Eyes)

I bought Almay eyeliner pencil because I heard it was the best for sensitive eyes. The pigment is not very good it takes a lot for it to stay on the bottom lash line %26 it doesn't stay very well. Trying to put it on upper lid lash line is no better. I wouldn't buy this eyeliner again also the eyeliner lead falls out of the pencil 😣

easy application, nice color. Worth the money

Love this eyeliner however I had to return it because I could not get the color I wanted and found out that Walmart is discontinuing this particular line of Alamay. I loved the gel and how smooth it goes on and stays on so well. I used the charcoal carbon color which had a little sparkle in it which I also really liked. I bought the black because I could not find the charcoal and was hoping if I waited long enough it would come back in and I could exchange it but it did not. That's when I found out they were no longer going to carry it. Very disappointed and I'm hoping I can find it in another store somewhere.

This eyeliner is amazing. It stays on, stays put, and glides on like butter. It's less than half the price of a high end liner that I used to buy. So much better for my eyes. I have no idea why there are such bad reviews. I've sharpened this pencil with a regular eye pencil sharpener and it works perfectly. Give it a go, ladies. Pay no attention to these bad reviews. It's a keeper!!!!

I'd give it a 5 because it's a really nice eyeliner, easy to apply and the color is just right for my eyes. But unless I haven't yet figured things out, once the crayon that's showing runs out, there's no way to get more of the crayon. Will keep checking to see if there's something I'm missing. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

I had used a twist up dark liner for years that stopped working on my older eyes. (57 and needing less eye makeup) I began experimenting, gel, liquid, etc. all too dark, heavy and hard to remove. This one fit my needs. I use the charcoal. I have greenish/hazel eyes. It has a nice shimmer which brightens my eye contour. My lashes are thin so the smudged looks helps with defining. Plus my hands aren't steady and I end up with brush liners all over my kid! I did think this was a twist up and was confused when twisting the bottom resulted in nothing happening. I used a solid pencil sharpener that I use to sharpen my good color drawing pencils. Turning slowly and just shaving off a bit. I do not try for a super sharp point but not an issue for me. The eyeliner has good staying power. Just let it set first I will purchase this again but if you want a dark, fine line, try a brush on.

Review is on the product not the delivery they used to have a retractable version for the eyeliner, but now I have to sharpen it and it doesn't work well the gel smashes as it sharpens and the rough edges from sharpening hurt my eyes.

All of the eyeliner came out of pencil when opened in one shot ! Still need to return

This product does not sharpen very well

I have sensitive eyes and need a hypoallergenic eyeliner not many companies have it. I have been using this product for more than a year but I have noticed in the last few months that it doesn't sharpen at all it is too soft and the end doesn't go on smoothly I am very disappointed