Almay Intense i-Color Gel Smooth Liner, Navy (For Blue Eyes)

I bought Almay eyeliner pencil because I heard it was the best for sensitive eyes. The pigment is not very good it takes a lot for it to stay on the bottom lash line %26 it doesn't stay very well. Trying to put it on upper lid lash line is no better. I wouldn't buy this eyeliner again also the eyeliner lead falls out of the pencil 😣

easy application, nice color. Worth the money

Love this eyeliner however I had to return it because I could not get the color I wanted and found out that Walmart is discontinuing this particular line of Alamay. I loved the gel and how smooth it goes on and stays on so well. I used the charcoal carbon color which had a little sparkle in it which I also really liked. I bought the black because I could not find the charcoal and was hoping if I waited long enough it would come back in and I could exchange it but it did not. That's when I found out they were no longer going to carry it. Very disappointed and I'm hoping I can find it in another store somewhere.

I really loved this product. It glides on so smooth and it lasts all day. The color is perfect. I really recommend that you try this out for yourself.

I'd give it a 5 because it's a really nice eyeliner, easy to apply and the color is just right for my eyes. But unless I haven't yet figured things out, once the crayon that's showing runs out, there's no way to get more of the crayon. Will keep checking to see if there's something I'm missing. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

I am a first time user for this gel eyeliner. It is smooth and stays for long hours. But sharpening is terrible. I had been using automation eyeliners that dont need a sharpener. But this liner doesnt have a sharpener, so I was confused on how to sharpen. The pencil body part, not gel, is very strong like plastic, so i couldnt use a razor blade to sharpen. Once I sharpened it with a sharpener that I got from other eyeliners, gel broke so easily, so I had to sharpen again. I will never buy again. I am going back to Revlon Colorstay automation liner.

Review is on the product not the delivery they used to have a retractable version for the eyeliner, but now I have to sharpen it and it doesn't work well the gel smashes as it sharpens and the rough edges from sharpening hurt my eyes.

All of the eyeliner came out of pencil when opened in one shot ! Still need to return

This product does not sharpen very well

I bought my Almay Gel Liner less than a month ago, after having given up on my Cover Girl Eye Liner which used to be wonderful. I used a few times and then found that it cannot be extended, let alone sharpened!!! Being desperate for eyeliner, I looked around my house for an object that is slender enough to fit in the end tube to shove the eyeliner down. I finally found that a matchstick works. However, it is only a short-term solution since the matchstick is shorter than the tube. Off to the store to buy a totally different self-sharpening eyeliner!!! Who tested this product, anyway?!!