Almay Multi-Benefit Mascara & All-Day Eyeliner Pencil Duo, Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Black Eyeliner and Black Brown Mascara, 1.1 oz, Black Eyeliner and Black Brown Mascara, 1.1 oz

This is my very first time trying this brand of mascara and eyeliner. I was very very pleased with my purchase. My eyes are sensitive and so I have a hard time wearing alot of brands but this does not bother my eyes at all. So great for sensitive eyes!

I am allergic to most make up and I can use this without any reaction!! It really is waterproof! Its not flaky and it lasts all day. Its also not clumpy or heavy. It goes on smooth. The color is rich and almost looks brown-black instead of just black. The brush is just a basic straight brush. For me, its a miracle I can wear it due to allergies. This is the first in years that doesnt break me out.

I have been using Almay mascara for a year or so. I like the quality of the product not lumpy and lengthens well. I also am allergic to other mascaras and this one works great.

I have not used the product as of yet. But upon doing research, it seems to be the safest mascara for eyes and eyelashes. I used Almay mascara many years ago, and was always satisfied with the quality of the product. Hopefully, I will be just as happy with this purchase!

I like the plain and simple brush. No fancy shape or bristles. Gentle and never causes eye irritation.

I like this mascara because it is nourishing and not drying to the eyelashes . It helps condition while giving that open eye look.

Just received this mascara. Have become somewhat allergic to all my other eye makeups and mascaras, even though they are not expired.

I use another waterproof Almay (which I thought I was purchasing). I just assumed they had changed the packaging. The brush was AWFUL. Luckily I saved the old brush to use with the new tube of mascara. About to throw this one away.

Nice, no smell, no fibers, does not flake but I had black under my eyes every time I wore it. It is waterproof ON my lashes, but I don't understand the smudging under my eyes. I do not rub my eyes.

Brush is nice but the product needs multiple coats to be visible on eyelashes ... then it is completely gone by mid-day.