My 3 dogs wouldn't eat them. They are not that picky. Then I noticed the ingredients...canola oil, citric acid, glycerin, veg oil?? Those are not good for us or our animals. I am stuck with 2 large containers, some may be okay with those ingredients and I was for 50 years but after my dogs started dying younger and younger, vaccine schedules became quicker/sooner and now they are using the RNA vaccines that are not good!!! Dog flu?? Our animals are being poisoned like we are to keep us sick, buy more drugs, more visits to vet, more money for drug companies. True!! Dogs need 1 rabies vax for their whole lifetime, they don't need boosters every year. My dogs growing up lived on our farm, went to vet every 5 years, never heard of dog flu, they lived longer and the past 25 years..I have been losing my babies faster the last 20 years...cancer, horrible!! My last baby was 10 and went in for yearly boosters, blood work great!! 1 week later, melted and died due to NO white blood cells, caused by allergic reaction to vax. NO MORE!! The 3, I have now are all rescues, my oldest is 13 and has tumors so I am on borrowed time. I hate that we live in a world where clean water, air, food is an issue and we are poisoned and lied to buy also, so happy research is possible. Sorry, soapbox! These supplements are not bad just not for my dogs!! DO RESEARCH!!