Carlo's Bakery Every Buddy's Birthday Slice, 6.8 oz, 1 Count, Refrigerated

Absolutely horrible! I was so disappointed. I really wanted to love it.. the bottom cake was hard as a rock and the date wasn't up for another week so it hadn't expired. I love dessert and I've never thrown away a cake before in my life, but unfortunately, I had to throw this one away. The cheesecake was gritty and the birthday cake in the middle would've been edible, but there was only an inch piece of it in the middle so there wasn't enough to really tell…. so overall I give it a half star.

The Best slice of store bought cake I've ever had! Makes me want try every flavor! Devilishly satisfying.

In the past, I have only tried the rainbow and red velvet cake slices. This was a first with the birthday cake slice.. loved the combination of different cakes put together. The blondie and cheesecake were a surprise and really went well with the bday spongecake. It was like three treats in one.. I'll have to try the chocolate one next time..

The cake was sugar overload!! Starting from the cake to the frosting ending with the cheesecake. What flavor is it supposed to be vanilla because all I could taste was sweetness. I'm hoping his special ordered cakes don't taste like this slice of cake I had.

I really liked each individual layer, they quality was really good. A whole piece was too much for me. I should have separated them and eaten each layer by itself. It's really rich and very sweet. I liked it but if I order it again I'll only eat 1 layer at a time. I think it's worth the price.

This was not good. I threw it away after a taste of each layer. It tasted old and crumbly. You could tell it had been frozen for a bit, or perhaps frozen defrost refrozen. All I know is it tasted weird. The blondie on the bottom was okay. The cake layer was dry and terrible. The cheesecake layer just tasted like sugar. Save yourself some money and do not buy this. They are selling you Carlos and not his quality of product. If he is associated with this I hope he pulls it and rethinks this item.

The blondie was hard and almost tasteless. The sponge cake and icing was tasteless. The cheescake part was okay. Not worth it.

it was extremely the frosting came right off the cake because it was so stale. it was the closest thing I've ever had in my life and I used to work in a bakery

Both me and my brother tried it. I was honestly craving Cake and I saw Carlos and I know he's a huge Italian guy from New Jersey if I remember correctly. But love his cake. It was moist sweet but not overly sweet. I'd say the Blondie was the most sweetest one, but everything else is perfect. It was dry. We definitely have Cake again and excited to try his cakes.

The entire thing tastes artificial, it reminds me of those "protein cookies" that taste nothing like actual cookies, yet somehow this is supposed to be normal cake. Cheesecake was the most disappointing of all as it had weirdly eggy flavor to it with only a hint of cheesecake. The rest was oddly thick and just tasted unpalatable.