Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty price history and forecast - Crazy Aaron's
Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty

Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty

Brand:
Crazy Aaron's
Model Number:
UPC:
810174290868
EAN:
0810174290868
ASIN:
B0FN4F38KH
Walmart SKU:
17500518013

Third-Party Seller Summary

Third-Party Seller Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$37.00
Lowest Price
$14.99
Most Recent Price
$22.95
Average Price
$25.85
First Tracked
Last Update

Walmart.com Summary

No price history available for Walmart.com

Price Analysis

Price history data is not available for this product at the moment.

Current Trend: No Walmart.com pricing data available for analysis.

Customer Insights: Rated 4.68/5 from 47 reviews.

Customer Reviews

47 reviews

Customer Reviews

4.7
Based on 47 reviews
5
41
4
2
3
1
2
1
1
2
Filter Reviews:
Sort By:
Showing 10 of 47 reviews

MUST TRY

Kristina September 3, 2025

I literally got this in the mail 5 minutes ago and it's incredible. I had to come make a review right away. It really does feel just like soft butter, I don't know how they did it. You HAVE to try it!!! Also, for anyone wondering (because I kind of did, lol) it does not have a butter scent.

Was this review helpful?

My new favorite!

Hello August 19, 2025

I never write reviews, but this putty deserved one. I have anxiety/sensory issues and I own many different putty's from this brand, but since I got this one I haven't been able to put it down! It's the perfect texture. It has all the pros of slime and other doughs but doesn't dry out! It's the thing I've been on the hunt for, and have showed all my friends and family. Will definitely be getting more.

Was this review helpful?

AMAZING PUTTY

ca124 August 17, 2025

LOVE this putty. It literally feels like melted butter- I have no idea how they were able to do this but it is amazing. This is like butter slime but better-all without ever drying out. This is my new favorite Crazy Aaron's texture, will be buying again!

Was this review helpful?

Amazing melted butter feeling

Buttered Popcorn August 22, 2025

When I heard that this putty would feel like a melted stick of butter in your hands, I knew I had to try it. The texture is really entirely different from any other putty I've felt from Crazy Aaron. It's really soft and almost melts in your hands without actually melting. It has an oily feeling but I don't think my hands are actually oily. It calmed me down after feeling stressed. Downside is that it kinda gets stuck in my nails. But that doesn't deter me from wanting to get another putty like this texture again. Please make more in different colors this texture. And try this putty out if you're into the softer putties, you won't regret it.

Was this review helpful?

I can't believe it's not butter!

raaawrbin September 3, 2025

I thought it would feel like the Scentsory putties but it is a completely different feel. It's soft and airy, feels oily like butter (but isn't actually, no residue on the hands) but still retains it's shape when you play with it.

Was this review helpful?

OMG it is like REAL BUTTER

cmarrero September 7, 2025

This is a smooth putty that feel like you took a stick of butter and squeezed it in your hand. It feels greasy but yours hand come out with nothing on them. Been showing friends and family this putty and I think they get why I love Crazy Aaron products. Gotta have a Stack of tins on your office desk it is a must have.

Was this review helpful?

AMAZING PUTTY

Bri August 21, 2025

Literally feels like a stick of butter I played with this for an hour straight it's so soft and in a way feels kinda slippery /oily but there's no residue at all! I'm addicted

Was this review helpful?

No, it literally feels like butter.

NClark August 28, 2025

Yep! Feels like squishing soft butter. The “oily” feeling took some getting used to for me, but once I got past that I have really enjoyed playing with this one. My only wish is that it came in the 3.2oz size like the other larger quantity putties.

Was this review helpful?

BEST OF THEM ALL

Katie December 24, 2025

I got this as a gift for chrtistmas, I have been collecting Aaron's for a WHILE... I have hundreds... ANYWAY this is my favorite! I want this to be in one of the giant tins!!!!!! I would buy like 5 giant tins of this stuff it's by far my absolute favorite. its so soothing to smoosh!

Was this review helpful?

Amazing!

rngiles September 7, 2025

Wow this putty is amazing! It really does feel just like softened butter. I love this putty and my friends who've tried it agreed. I hope they do more with this texture in the future

Was this review helpful?

Price History

Historical price data graph for Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty

Recent Price Changes

Detailed price history for the past 90 days

Walmart.com Pricing

0 records

No Walmart.com pricing data available for analysis.

No Walmart price history available in the past 90 days

Third-Party Seller Pricing

10 records

Third-Party Sellers prices have ranged from $22.95 (Jun 19) to $37.00 (May 17) over the past 90 days. Current price is 18.1% below the 90-day average of $28.02.

Third-party seller price history for Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty showing recent price changes
Date Price Change % Change
$22.95 $-0.02 -0.1%
$22.97 $-0.03 -0.1%
$23.00 $-0.50 -2.1%
$23.50 $-0.97 -4.0%
$24.47 $+0.00 +0.0%
$24.47 $-8.02 -24.7%
$32.49 $-2.00 -5.8%
$34.49 $-0.41 -1.2%
$34.90 $-2.10 -5.7%
$37.00

Related Products