I switch back and forth between this stuff and Old Spice Denali. In comparative terms, this has a way better stick/carton, it's easier to move up, and the stuff inside isn't so easily broken if you drop it.
The stuff itself - this is harder/crumblier than the Old Spice, which is greasier. I guess the Spice feels better going on, but leaves more white residue on your clothes, this goes on drier, but you have to be careful not to over apply and get white flakes. Sort of a draw.
In terms of effectiveness, the Spice does keep me slightly drier, that's the big drawback to this stuff. I never get too sweaty on this, just more than on Spice. The flip side, the smell of this stuff combined with sweat smells awesome, like strangers in elevators tell me how great I smell awesome. So on that basis... it would be the top pick, in my mind. Definitely recommend.