Have only had to try overpatches for a couple of years now, but we first went with Right Patch. The first package was acceptable but didn't stick as well as we had hoped. The second package would barely stick and literally looked like they were hand cut by kindergarteners. We trimmed as they fell apart, but the next one wouldn't ever cover where needed.
We are now on our third Peelz patch, and what a blessing they have been. One lasts the entire ten days and holds the sensor in place, so better readings are achieved. Absolutely great product! Thank you.