e.l.f. Expert Liquid Liner, Midnight, 0.14 fl oz

I have used this eyeliner for a few months and wore it everyday to school and it stayed on all day and didn't smudge unless I smudged it and applies well

Ho comprato questo prodotto 3 mesi fa e lo trovo perfetto per fare un eyeliner sfumato

I am a long-term fan of dramatic winged eyeliner. This is the best liquid liner I have found and I have tried so many brands I have lost track. I am actually writing this review purely because the sole review for this product currently is one star which is madness! This glides on beautifully, it doesn't crumble, and if - like me - you suffer from teary eyes that smudge whatever you put in your outer corner, you can rest assured that this liner WILL. NOT. BUDGE.

I could not believe that this eyeliner would be better to my previous ones that were also expensive. I've got deep set eyes and I used to really struggle using eyeliner but this brush has made it unbelievable easy to me. I am really happy with the deep dark colour and that fact that it doesn't smudge. It's not waterproof but that's not a problem for me as I want to be able to remove it with water and not lotions or any other chemicals.

Jet Black: I have had this for a while now and I love how precisely it applies. The colour is buildable and it's very nice to use Coffee: I got this recently and its patchy; the colour is nice but not buildable making it difficult to use Moondust: Looks really pretty but for some reason feels tightening? On the whole I would only recommend the black one but for the price you are paying there isn't much room for complaint

An okay product, easy to apply and easy wash off but also comes off when snowing, raining or sweat due to hot day or other activities that cause perspiration.

The pro is you can actually get this where you want it and it doesn't dry out after a couple uses like the “pen” type liquid liners. Con is it gets a crackly look after a few hours of use ...so I strategically top with black shadow to help mask this ...and it crumbles like crazy when removing. So, it's OK but not fabulous. Like that it is animal friendly and a great price.

This is hands down the worst eyeliner I've ever bought. It took over a full minute to dry and bled out everywhere. I had to put on 3/4 coats because the black I ordered turned out very grey and watery, the applicator is too thin and is hard to control. Took off my makeup and put it straight in the bin, complete waste of money.

it was So Watery, that when I tried to use it, it bled into my eye and turned part of it black for a second before I wiped it away-so you could say it's not ideal for easy application. The tip is too thick to be precise without wiping the extra eyeliner off the stick first and The formula is pretty blotchy too. When I tried to use it on my eyelid the handle got eyeliner all over and it smudged before it was able to dry, so forget waterline, cat eyes wings and well everything eyeliner should do-this is just not that versatile. I don't know what it's supposed be for since it doesn't actually work for what it says. I tried to like it but threw it out after two uses (which I don't ever do, I just can't see myself using this.) it may seem like a good price but anything is too expensive (no matter the price) if it's not what you want. I'm a bit disappointed, because I was hoping this would be another elf five stars, but instead my first one star. It could have been a bad batch, or something so I'm not telling you not to buy it, I'm just saying my experience was not worth it. Thank you for reading and I hope your experience was better then mine!

Very translucent and feels watery compared to other brands. Comes off easily so bleeding is noticeable as well as smudging. I like elf but this is one of their worst products. I don't know if midnight is supposed to be blue but I originally thought it would be black. In dark light it seems like black but when light hits, you can tell it's blue.