e.l.f. H2O Proof Inkwell Eyeliner, Bluebird, 0.11 fl oz

This eyeliner is amazing! I bought the white and deep purple one. They both are very waterproof and stay on all day! Applicator is easy to use. Love it

Got this as a semi hand-me-down as it's not the usual kind of eyeliner I'd buy but WOW am I glad I got It. This stays on all day and does not budge- even as someone whose eyes naturally water all the mf time. The applicator takes a little practice to get to grips with, but is great once you're used to it and took me less than a week (used eyeliner a lot but with different applicators). When i got this for the first time, the product was a few months old and had hardly been used but after that it went on to last me another 9 months of almost daily use where after a while the brush did get a little claggy, but could easily be cleared with a wipe. But yeah, pair this with some kohl or kajal on your water/lash lines, mascara and some glittery eyeshadow if you want and you will SLAY!! I've got this in black (second purchase) and brown and atp owe my firstborn to this eyeliner

Love this liner it is absolutely the best! I've tried them all and this is number one!

Great eyeliner I receive many compliments. Very easy to apply.

Love the thin brush of this eyeliner. It make it easy to get right along the lash line. I like a thin line because I can be sure the tightline matches. Stays on all day until I take it off with makeup remover.

Like the color and the price… the liner wand doesn't always perform as I'd like… skips sometimes - or clots.

I thought this may take the place of the waterproof Sephora felt/liquid liner in cobalt. However, this blue is way too light. It appears that others use this liner for face painting, as shown in the photos. people u

Great. The only problem with his eyeliner is that the color is just too light for what I need. I need an eyeliner for tightlining, not face painting. And stick with a gel for the waterline. Other than that, the felt applicator is awesome, and it IS waterproof.

Ithought this came with a brush applicator, not a foam tip. Tip clogs and doesnt distribute liquid evenly. it did smudge some even with primer.

I got this product for free using my points, and thank goodness for that. I would have been so mad if I had wasted my money on this. I applied this the moment I got it because I was excited. I've been needing a new liquid eyeliner. I sat around for about 8 hours editing video. That's it. The first time I looked in the mirror a couple hours after applying, I noticed a lot of this product flaking off and a little bit of smudging on my eyelid. At the end of the day, my eyelids were black! For being waterproof, this has insanely low staying power. I didn't sweat, my face was clean to start with, and I literally sat around all day. Maybe some other products are needed to make this work, or maybe it's a me problem, but I'm glad I didn't spend money on it. It's a bummer, too. There are so many cute colors I was excited to try. But alas, there are other eyeliners!