e.l.f. H2O Proof Waterproof Eyeliner Pen, Jet Black 81109, 0.02 fl oz

I'm admittedly cheap when I buy makeup but I do buy nice things if it's worth the money. That being said, I have no reason to spend more on eyeliner because this little pin is amazing. It goes on smooth. It lasts all day and I will continue to come back to this product versus going and paying more.

I am used to the Hauslabs eyeliner by Lady Gaga, which was discontinued, and I have to say that it's as easy as that one to apply, just the tip is a bit shorter. It's very waterproof and won't smudge, but it's very hard to remove. So get an oil for that!

The only eyeliner I use anymore. Beautiful black pigment, truly waterproof, long lasting, great value. I have only used it on my upper lid because I'm afraid to use it on the bottom. I'm scared I'll poke my eyeball, but that's a personal issue. Nothing wrong with the product.

Fabulous pigmented eyeliner that glides on with no colour skipping and stays put. Please keep this eyeliner in stock as it is the best I've tried in a very long time

I wanted to test the h2o proof claim to this so I actually wore it to the beach and swimming. I will say I don't wear makeup to the beach so I didn't have anything else on to help it stay. However, it did stay mostly on through sweating, wind and swimming in lake Michigan. So I really like it. It should hold up well for what I need and it looks great!

I've had a number of different black liquid liners over the years, and my biggest frustrations have either been that they're “too dry” with not enough flow and/or the pen dries out too fast, OR they're “too liquidy” and the liquid takes too long to dry on the lid, thus smudging and forming and extra line in the area above my eyelid. This liner, however, is “just right”!!! It's perfect. It flows so well with just the right about of fluid, and it dries immediately, so it never smudges! It also stays on all day! I absolutely love it, and it makes me so happy to use it.

Great eyeliner pencil for the price.

I love this liner. It's affordable and very easy to apply. It can fade or transfer throughout the day if you have oily skin like myself, but I don't mind touching it up. Will continue to purchase.

It is the best eyeliner I have found, waterproof, doesn't smudge, and stays on. BUT the packaging is awful. I've had two - the first one the cap kept flying off and it dried out almost immediately, and my second one has cap problems too but this time it leaks.

The tip went dry after a week. I wouldnt reccomend.