e.l.f. Intense Ink Eyeliner, Blackest Black

Easy to use, big brush, not waterproof or rub-proof though

I really like the fat tip and the boldness of the black but for me it seems to dry out too quickly and that might be partly to do with the amount of shadow I wear.

I am absolutely useless at liquid eyeliner but this makes it so easy! It is a very bold black so more suitable for nights out. It is difficult to remove but means it lasts quite well. I have a feeling it may dry out quite easily in time though.

I usually love anything e.l.f. comes out with, but this eyeliner really hit the epic fail. It was difficult to use as even brand new i had to stop %26 shake it to keep the tip properly filled. It has zero staying power. Frequent reapplication was par for the course. The color was intense %26 deep - just what I love from a liquid eyeliner, but overall this was a very disappointing product.

Makes an easy straight line. Ease of use is nice and takes a while to not run out. It is very fast drying and doesn't need a sharpener! Which is nice!

I don't know if the formula it's very dry or my eyeliner came dry because I was able to do one eye and that was all :( I can't use it anymore because nothing it's coming out. It's a shame because the color was good and intense and also I find the application very easy, hence the 2 stars, otherwise it will be just one. I had to throw it away.

When I first bought it, the colour was really dark. But it dried out so quickly and the colour is now more grey than black. The product itself doesn't smudge and stays on a long time but the pigmentation isn't great. But what can you expect for such a cheap price.

Bad. I love elf but this is just bad. It's not black, it's gray. Brand new eyeliner and it doesn't even apply well. It applies like I've used it on the heaviest cakey eyeshadow and it clogged it up - but I had no eyeshadow on! Will be returning

I want to start this off by saying I have been doing graphic eyeliner on myself for years and get loads of compliments. I ran out of my usual brand and picked this up to use for now. I could not even finish one eye before it seemed to run out. The pigment is spotty, the marker feels dry, you have to put way too much pressure to get any good colour coming out of the tip. I ended up covering up my eyeliner with black eyeshadow to cover up the missing spots and uneven lines. This is frustrating as I generally really like ELF products.

Was already well on its way to being dried out after opening it for the very first time. The tip has zero color which makes it very difficult to achieve a sharp look. Trash.