Freshness Guaranteed 4-inch S'mores Mini Baked Pie, 4 oz (Shelf Stable), Paperboard Box

I finally got to taste these. my last attempt was rather scary. these are pretty darn good. I recommend them. it's a good mix of custard and chocolate. I don't think they're too healthy, but a Sunday and Sunday the doctor said was all right. he actually encouraged it saying it discourages me from breaking my diet. so I'll continue to get my sweet tooth taken care of a couple times a month with one of these. I especially like the size, a perfect portion. and if you just want to be romantic and you're not too hungry or you want to get to the romantic side quicker? split one with your partner.

problem is this was the chocolate eclair pie in the wrong box, they are identical except for the filling. One is custard, one marshmallow ??? Chocolate eclair is outstanding ,!! Good thing I ordered 3 of each but looks like I got 6 eclairs...

I really enjoyed this Smores pie! It was so fresh and yummy! I also loved the price. It makes a great lunch snack because they are sold individually. You gotta try these! Delicious!

The only part that is flavored is the chocolate drizzle on top. This is dry and hard and crackes off to fall in your lap or plate if you're eating at the table. The filling is flavorless marshmallow goo. The crust is flaky but plain. Nothing special to recommend it. You might try nuking it and adding some more chocolate sauce. Or a graham cracker. The original version was made with graham crackers.

it had a little too much marshmallow and not enough chocolate. would have also been better with a graham cracker crust. would have tasted more like a s'mores.

The crust was a bit deceiving. The filling was baked so that it mostly melted away. About all that was left was crust, and it wasn't all that good either.

Recently, Wal-mart has raised the price of many of their mini-baked pies by almost 20%... except for this one. After trying it, it's not hard to see why. This is pitched as a "S'mores Pie." In reality, it's a normal pie filled with very cheap marshmallow fluff and a squiggle of chocolate frosting on top that has turned to stone in the time since leaving the factory. I suppose the pie crust is supposed to taste like a graham cracker, and checking the ingredients I do notice it was made using "graham flour", but there is absolutely no graham cracker flavor. You are basically eating a giant heaping spoonful of marshmallow fluff and can't really taste much else a round it. I visibly shuddered after two bites of this thing. Feels like something cheap they made out of scraps they had lying around.

I bought one box for each guest to serve as dessert at the birthday party. I was so disappointed and embarrassed. The dessert did not taste anything like a S'more. The crust was soggy, and the filling was mushy instead of firm. The 'Freshness Guaranteed' claim was not valid for this boxed product.

First off I did not order the smores pie ,but they delivered it to me. In my order I requested chocolate puding pie! Second it dd not even taste anything like a smores ! It was gross!

I usually love these mini pies that Walmart sells. These new eclair/ marshmallow ones are terrible. They taste like sugary pudding inside. The "chocolate" is candy melts not real and was crumbly and loose in the box. I wouldn't buy em again