Freshness Guaranteed Amish Macaroni Salad, Ready to Serve, 32 oz Tub (Refrigerated)

I come from a family of Pennsylvania Dutch, all of the foods that you carry are wonderfully tasting, so I am not as homesick as I think I am, being away at school, thank you Walmart for your shown kindness in helping me to be able to eat foods that I am used to eating.

The taste is delicious. My husband loves it, and it does not make him sick. My daughter and I love it too; however, it makes both of us sick to our stomach. There has to be an ingredient in it that makes us sick - or - maybe it stays unrefrigerated for over an hour by the time it is delivered to us.

I have been buying this Amish macaroni salad for years. It was very close to the authentic flavor I grew up with. Sadly, it seems the formula has been changed. It is quite bland. If you want to doctor it up, you can get it to actually taste like something. I won't buy it again and don't recommend. The Amish Potato salad has suffered the same fate as well.

The Amish macaroni salad is fantastic . . Most macaroni salads macaroni salads bother my stomach because of to much sweet peppers within . I love the shredded carrots, in fact I always add in more with a little graded parmesan when I really like is the carrots, in fact, I add more carrots to it as well. I really like the carrots, in fact, I also add in parmesan cheese. DELICIOUS 😋

Bog-standard macaroni salad that is too sweet. Nothing special. You would think that with the name "Amish" it would have less sugar, but it still has too much sugar. I don't know why another reviewer said it needed more sugar, maybe its a batch issue or made by hand inconsistently.

I love this amish macaroni salad. It has a very good taste, but if it had onions in it, it would taste even better. Sometimes you can taste onions in it and that's when it's very delicious and sometimes you can't taste the onions. I would rate it a five with the onions.

I love the this macaroni salad! I am not an onion fan and this salad does not give you all onion. It has hard boiled egg and it is creamy. I love the sweetness and depending on who makes it, it either is sweet or needs a little more sugar. That's just me. I love a salad that is more sweet than vinegary. But it is great.

This mac salad straight up tastes like sugar. It is far too sweet, and even with adding extra mustard black pepper, it was barely edible. I do not recommend unless you want to eat your mac salad for dessert.

Love this Amish mac salad and all Walmart salads but the prices for the deli salads are too expensive. I'm now making big batches of my own for less than half the cost.

Macaroni Salad, potato salad, and things like that are items that not everyone can agree on. I’ve watched food competition shows that show just how differently people prepare their salads, starting with WHAT they put in it…mayo and miracle whip can cause division alone. As for this Amish Macaroni Salad, it is SWEETer than a typical Mac salad. For me, that is a win because it is absolutely DELICIOUS! If your kiddos are picky eaters, they might like it because it is sweeter and has a tangy hint to it than most Mac salads. Veggies in it are crispy but small enough that they don’t take center stage away from the macaroni.