Freshness Guaranteed Chocolate Peanut Butter Creme Pie, 12 oz Tray

We tried a few different pies of the same brand that I picked up for a party. This chocolate peanut butter one was the one that looked the best but was no ones favorite. The top layer of chocolate cool whip texture was good but the underneath is like a gooey peanut butter jelly and was kinda weird. I'll admit it was much better cold but in the store it wasn't refrigerated so it wasn't cold for our party.

I had high hopes for this pie. It looked and sounded absolutely delicious. It looked appealing with the peanut butter whipped cream, chocolate drizzle and peanut butter chips. That top layer and the crust is good. However the creme really threw me off. I was expecting a peanut butter flavor. It tasted almost fruity? It was super weird and did not taste good with the topping. A few of us tried it and we all thought the same thing. Not sure if we just got a bad one or what but I wouldn't purchase this again.

This tastes like mayonnaise?? 9 people tried it and only one person enjoyed it. Not much peanut butter flavor and there was a sourness that reminded several of us of mayonnaise. I would have given it one star except that one person enjoyed it. Much smaller than expected but that's fine because we didn't enjoy it. Never again.

I wish I had seen the other reviews! This is Horrible ! Also mine came and was not sealed ! The lid just pops off , no tape ! Again another item that is causing me to start doing my own shopping ! So much for connivence. Do better Walmart

Absolutely disgusting. Tastes like chemicals and sadness. The main pie layer is a gel subtance that doesn't resemble peanut butter at all.

I like to think I’m somewhat of a connoisseur of peanut butter pie! I love the rich taste of peanut butter with the slight hint of chocolate and prefer a graham cracker crust! I’ve had many of peanut butter pie in my time but this one was different!!! It tasted like a hot garbage tub of sour cream fresh out of the dumpster!!! I spit out the first bite and immediately confided in my wife to get her opinion on if the pie had expired! She barely touched it with the tip of her tongue and immediately showed signs of discuss that confirmed that indeed I was eating a hot garbage tub of sour cream!!! DO NOT EAT THIS PIE!!!!

NOT chocolate inside its like a tan colored mixture. Im not sure what it is but its! DISGUSTING! Went in the garbage.

It doesn't taste like peanut butter. Sure it's a pie but someone filled it with hate, and spite. I ended up with reget for my friend's birthday.

This pie is about 6”-7” across. The crust is pale, thick and “dough-y”. The top layer is a piped, whipped peanut butter flavored “frosting”, drizzled with the tiniest drizzle of chocolate that has no discernible flavor. There is a half dozen peanut butter chips sprinkled on top. The worst part is the “Creme” filling that’s seems unconnected to peanut butter aspect of the pie. It feels like this nondescript pale, flavorless pudding-like Creme and the crust is a standard base used for every flavor of these pies, no matter what flavor they put into the topping. Never been so disappointed with a sweet dessert.

It tastes like it is going rancid. Not what was expected. This first bite was a bit of a punch. It tasted a little sour. This pie has an almost lemon tang at the end. It is not very chocolatey. I will not be buying this pie again. I did not even finish the slice I cut for myself. I was very disappointed by this pie, and so were my kids. I would love my money back, as it went into the garbage.