Freshness Guaranteed Peanut Butter Bakery Baked Cookies, 14 oz, 10 Count
- Brand:
- Freshness Guaranteed
- Model Number:
- UPC:
- 194346267521
- EAN:
- 0194346267521
- Walmart SKU:
- 5579027106
Trending upward with a $0.47 move recently to reach $3.44. Current price runs 4.8% above the 90-day average.
| Price Type | Price | Date |
|---|---|---|
|
Highest Price
|
$3.84 | |
|
Lowest Price
|
$2.97 | |
|
Most Recent Price
|
$3.44 |
Tracking History: We have tracked Freshness Guaranteed Peanut Butter Bakery Baked Cookies, 14 oz, 10 Count since 3/12/2025. The most recent price update was on Nov 18, 2026.
Price Range: Over the past 90 days, the price has ranged from $2.97 (lowest on 5/25/2026) to $3.84 (highest on 4/14/2026). The average price during this period is $3.34.
Current Trend: Walmart.com prices have ranged from $2.97 (Sep 14) to $3.44 (Nov 17) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $3.28.
Customer Insights: Rated 4.5/5 from 7051 reviews.
The cookies use to be the best peanut butter cookies that I've tasted. I was so very disappointed the last (3) three times that I've bought them. The taste and texture is definitely not the same. It appears that the recipe changed, or that there's a new baker that's not following the original recipe. What a shame, what a pity, and I loved these cookies, and even shared them with others multiple times. Unfortunately I want buy them anymore. Hopefully this message will reach the bakery department and they come up with a solution to fix this issue.
The cookies taste pretty good. The problem I have is, only with the fact that Walmart doesn't take the pride or time to ensure that it can't just be opened by anyone except the person who buys it!! An extra step to add a tamper resistance sticker would be excellent!!
The cookies are soft and chewy just not enough peanut butter for my taste. However, my husband loves these cookies, I just wish they had more flavor for when I grave sweetness. Tasty when dipped in milk it does enhance the flavor. Not good with tea just has a strange aftertaste. My husband has a craving for these cookies, I am basically giving my personal opinion which may differ from others.
They don't even taste like peanut butter! Who wants a peanut butter cookie made with cheap crappy ingredients? These went straight into the trash. 3 of us tried these and we all spit it out, cause it didn't taste like a peanut butter cookie should. I'm not shopping in the bakery at Walmart anymore. Worst experiences.
These are our favorite cookies from Walmart!! They have a softness and sweetness, but not too sweet. I love that you can literally take them and break them in half so easily. They are very addictive; you will have a craving for them. I really wish I could go in the back and learn how they make these, as well as the recipe. That would be so amazing!! I will keep buying these peanut butter cookies for my family and me. Great with coffee!
The worst cookies I've ever purchased! I took 2 bites of one cookie and immediately discarded ALL of them. The cookie is not overly sweet--the only positive I could find about this purchase. Weird texture--so soft I wondered if they were microwaved instead of baked. While there were a limited number of small peanut pieces in each cookie, there was no peanut butter taste about them. I can hardly believe that someone in Walmart's bakery thinks this recipe is good enough to sell to customers. My recommendation? Buy something else!
I was shocked by how good the peanut butter cookies are! .. I have always prefered home backed goods, but this brand of PB cookies was a game changer for me! .. Baked perfect, soft and great PB flavor! . Very very close to homemade😃. .. Do want to note that I think they are made with crunchy peanut butter. .. I am not a fan of crunchy pb but there is only a tiny bit of peanut slithers in the cookies which were barely noticeable to me. .. Great cookies! .. Much, much better cookies than the packaged cookies in the snack isles.
I used to buy Wal-Mart cookies all the time, and they were just right with the texture.. I guess these were okay, too, as the Sugar Cookies were, compared to the Cinnamon Raisin ones. I just don't get why they didn't even say "Chewy" on them, neither. I bought another flavor—besides these and the Cinnamon Raisin ones—but they were the same way but not as bad as the the Cinnamon Raisin.. Unfortunately, I had to give them all the same Rating/Review as this. If it wasn't for the softness, I think I would've loved them; especially these and the Sugar Cookies.. but, I just can't get passed that! I don't like chewy cookies; I don't like them hard, neither.. I like them in-between—Just right, like Goldilocks!
Usually these cookies are pretty good. I don't know what happened with the 2 boxes I ordered. They had way too mild peanut butter taste. As I held the cookie it began to fold over and break into 3 pieces. Not baked long enough. I will try them again.
Very tasty and SOFT peanut butter cookies. Well, mostly soft. Until you bite into the little bits of nuts that are all throughout the cookies. Which tend to get stuck in your teeth, even if you don't have any teeth problems... But anyway, that's why I have given these cookies 4 stars instead of 5. What would really be great, is if they could make another version of these available that didn't have the little nuts in them. And it would be in their best interest to, since they would probably sell more of them. Because I have actually stopped buying them BECAUSE of the nuts in them.
Detailed price history for the past 90 days
Walmart.com prices have ranged from $2.97 (Sep 14) to $3.44 (Nov 17) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $3.28.
| Date | Price | Change | % Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| $3.44 | $+0.00 | +0.0% | |
| $3.44 | $+0.00 | +0.0% | |
| $3.44 | $+0.00 | +0.0% | |
| $3.44 | $+0.47 | +15.8% | |
| $2.97 | $+0.00 | +0.0% | |
| $2.97 | — | — |