The cookies themselves were fairly good. Some arrived cracked/smashed. Some didn't have a verse in them. Some of them were cut wrong/miscut - so you only got a few words from one verse, or two parts from 2 different verses. Considering how much could be taken from the bible, we feel like there could have been a better mixture of verses - more/different sayings. Overall, we love that they have bible verses instead of fortunes/lucky numbers. They also come individually wrapped, which is nice, especially if you are bringing them to share with others. Overall, the quality/quality control of the verses and having intact cookies could be a little better, hence the 4 star rating. Would still buy them again. They should be cheaper for what you get, or they should improve the quality though