No one expects top tier quality for something like this. From first looks, these are acceptable, especially at the price point (30 for $15). However, I would have given the product a 3 1/2 star rating* and a qualified recommendation*, if those were options. The description said boxes were randomized, but the 2nd box we ordered (a couple of days after the 1st) was EXACTLY like the 1st box . . . EXACTLY . . . 100% identical. So, there was zero chance of getting the Statue of Liberty or green alien duck that my daughter wanted. We planned to buy up to 4 boxes in hopes of finding Lady Liberty (my daughter LOVES Lady Liberty), but now we dare not try again. As far as the ducks go, we plan to hand them out at Halloween for kids who prefer trinkets to treats. (We are considering getting a corn hole game %26 handing them out as prizes.) The search for an affordable Statue of Liberty rubber ducky (outside of NYC) continues.
*3 1/2 stars is for the 100% duplication . . . most customers likely aren't expecting that outcome for multiple randomized boxes and the qualified recommendation is for the same reason. If you are looking for 30 decent ducks at $15, then I'd give this 4 1/2 stars and a solid recommendation.