[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] If I could rate a 2.5, right in the middle, I would! Some of these markers were a hit, some were a miss. For context, I used them on a whiteboard, so I don't have a reference for how they may work on other surfaces. But this was my experience: I appreciate that they came with instructions on how to get the marker started. It's a little tedious, but it's the same process you need to do with any type of paint marker. I did have one marker's tip get stuck down inside, so I shook it really hard with the cap off....don't do that! That was user error, but I splattered purple all over my floor. Make sure to shake with the cap on like the instructions say. Unfortunately, some of the markers arrived to me already "activated," which meant the color was thin and dried out. You can see in one of my attached photos which colors wrote bold and clear, while others were more watery. (You can even see the white show up on the white board which was a fun surprise!) Keep in mind, these are NOT dry-erase markers. They'll erase just fine, but I wouldn't recommend using your finger or hand like some might do with dry-erase markers. The color won't flake off and disintegrate like a dry-erase marker, it'll just transfer to your hand and you'll need to wash it off. I wouldn't even recommend using an eraser meant for white boards. You should use something disposable like a paper towel or tissue. It's a bit of a bummer that the QR code on the box takes you to a website that isn't set up yet, but that's a minor detail. The markers are supposed to be "reversible" which I didn't quite understand until I realized I think you're genuinely just supposed to pull the tip out with your fingers and flip it around. (Haven't done so myself because I don't want to make a mess and get my fingers covered in liquid chalk.) One side of the tip is bullet tip and the other is chiseled. It does come with some extra tips as well. Overall, they're cool to have, and I'll keep using them on my whiteboard. They're definitely not a dry-erase replacement, but they'd be fun for a temporary art project or decorating windows for a special event!