The stove drips pans were heavy duty and appeared like the single ONE I have, (only have one that's about ten years old, gave the rest to my mother). The old one still looks new, shiny and clean. This pack came wrapped, yet already has a few dark spots or rusty looking spots that I tried washing away. There are tiny chipped edges around burner hole area. I want my stove to look clean, not dirty. Otherwise, they will do the job of protecting my white stove top(as long, as the rusty looking spots don't transfer over!)