L'Oreal Paris HiP Studio Secrets Professional Kohl Eyeliner, Black

Great could be a little blacker

Perfect for tightlining your eyes! The black color does not appear irridescent on me. Looks dark, matte and opaque like a true kohl liner. I apply it by closing my eyes and dragging the tip between my closed lids. Takes a bit of practice but this is the best way to get your water line and minimize fallout.

This eyeliner at first glance was pretty scary with the pointed applicator and all, but after watching a few tutorials and experimenting I found that it worked better on the waterline of the eye, good staying power, had to reapply only once after 8 hrs of work. I would definitely but this product again in all different colors.

I loved the product at first. It looks great and stays on great. But it is messy to apply (gets on checks). Then after a week or so, the texture changes and it doesn't go on as well and the tip of the applicator starts to curl. I bought a second one just to see if maybe the first one was just bad, but the same things happened. I love how it looks, I've been looking for something like it for a long time, but there are too many cons. I don't think I will be purchasing it again.

This eyeliner is very weird and hard to use. The wand inside is the same exact hard felt tip that most liquid eyeliner bottles have, though it really does not work for this product. Because the product is a powder, when you use the wand included yeah, you get it on your lids as liner, but also a LOT on powder falls down into your eyes and cheeks. When I've tried to use a different brush with it it's hard to get it in the bottle. The color is pretty, but...

I was disappointed at how the bits flake onto your cheeks. this is not smudgeproof. It is dry in the container but does have a fabulous applicator. Not bad, but I prefer their bencils and I am disappointed of the 4 color selection there. i'd love to see these colors in the pencils.

I love the intense color and the soft line, but this stuff is impossible to apply without getting it on your cheeks and any excess sticks like glue, so I have to use makeup remover to clean up the fallout and tidy up the lines. Then I have to reapply my foundation and concealer, etc. It seems like a great idea, but is just too hard to apply. What a waste of my money. Also, the Navy Kohl has very little blue in it. It looks more like deep charcoal grey.

I love the color and it does stay on like other reviews stated but the applicator is hard and doesn't seem to work well on the upper lid and yes a ton falls on my cheek and gets everywhere so I have to redo my powder. I had hoped to find a video on this site to show me what I am doing wrong but no luck. I am taking it back to the store.

I liked the color and how is stayed on my eyes but after a month or less the eyeliner brush curls and is hard to apply. I thought I must have did something to the brush at first so I bought another and the same thing happened. Very disappointed with applicator... difficult to use .

I thought I was purchasing a liquid eyeliner but what I got instead was a bit of a mess. It isn't liquid so I'm not sure if the product I purchased was flawed or faulty; or is it by design. When I attempted to apply the eyeliner, I ended up with a cheek full of powdery dark brown. Very frustrating since I had to remove my foundation and reapply. Is this eyeliner supposed to be powdery or liquid?