L'Oreal Paris Infallible Matte-Matic Mechanical Eyeliner, Ultra Black

Would like it to be a little cheaper

I am on my second tube of Matte-Matic in dark brown. I LOVED the liner at first. Goes on slick and dark...but after a while the first tube got very dry and would barely go on my eye. Once it was gone I bought a new tube and, again, it's great. Hopefully I go through this tube before it gets dry

I can't give an accurate review as the item didn't show up in my Walmart delivery order. I'd be happy to give a better one if I can get one sent to me.

I bought this 3 weeks ago knowing how great L'Oréal products are. I didn't read all the reviews regarding this item. At first the eyeliner does go on smoothly, but as you keep lining your eye it starts to hurt. The eyeliner goes on very dry and it tugs your skin. I have tryed using the eyeliner several times and it just won't work for me. It hurts and tugs your skin as you try to line your eyes. Such a waste of money. I love L'Oréal products but I can't recommend this product.

I bought this eyeliner without reading any reviews and was too confident that it is going to work well. I regret so much buying this eyeliner, so hard to apply on, not much color appeared and it is very patchy giving my eyes horrible looks. Besides that, the eyeliners breaks while I was applying them, now I basically have half of it left after giving it several tries. AND it smudges so quickly. VERY DISAPPOINTED.

This is the worst eye liner I have ever purchased. I am very disappointed in this product. First, when I bought it, the whole eye liner pencil core fell out. Second, application was not smooth at all. It would not glide on to my eye lid. I had to apply a lot of pressure to get it to go on my lid. Also, it was not dark or a smooth line over my lid. This eyeliner is not worth spending the money on. I won't be buying Loreal eye products in the future.

I am very disappointed in the quality and performance of this product. The first time I used it the tip went very flat and too broad for an eye liner. With each use, the tip gets even flatter and now completely unusable after only 3 or 4 attempts at application. I usually buy L'Oréal products as they usually stand up for quality, but not this one.

bought this eyeliner and it broke first application. then continues to break and crumble if I try to use any remainder of the product.. such a waste of money :(

I bought this just 5 minutes ago. I was so horrified at how unusable this product was I decided to write this review. Overall, the pencil is so dry and it cannot be applied to the eye and as I keep trying to make it work it literally crumbles.

I purchased this in every shade because I love the idea of a matte liner. These things are so dry I cannot make them deposit any color onto my actual lids. I have even tried using in my waterline and no color comes off! Disappointing.