L'Oreal Paris Infallible Matte-Matic Mechanical Eyeliner, Ultra Black

Liner is smooth and easy to apply. Also washes off quickly

I am on my second tube of Matte-Matic in dark brown. I LOVED the liner at first. Goes on slick and dark...but after a while the first tube got very dry and would barely go on my eye. Once it was gone I bought a new tube and, again, it's great. Hopefully I go through this tube before it gets dry

I'm torn with this product. It holds up well with being long lasting but it gets really dry to apply after a couple of uses. It's not a nice smooth application and if you expose too much of the eyeliner out of the tube, with the amount of pressure you need to apply it, it tends to break off because you need to apply more pressure because it's dry.

Not as good as 16 hr Infallible. Lasts about 3 hours. I am not buying the Matte-Matic again.

I can't give an accurate review as the item didn't show up in my Walmart delivery order. I'd be happy to give a better one if I can get one sent to me.

dislike because keeps crumbing / breaking with very little pressure.

This item I usually get works excellent. This one I was given was super dry broke and I wasn't able to use it. And they wouldn't accept a return when I was given a dried eyeliner

when I took the cap off the liner flew out on the floor. easy to put back in but dry as a rock and did not work at all. will not order from them again

I bought this eyeliner without reading any reviews and was too confident that it is going to work well. I regret so much buying this eyeliner, so hard to apply on, not much color appeared and it is very patchy giving my eyes horrible looks. Besides that, the eyeliners breaks while I was applying them, now I basically have half of it left after giving it several tries. AND it smudges so quickly. VERY DISAPPOINTED.

This is the worst eye liner I have ever purchased. I am very disappointed in this product. First, when I bought it, the whole eye liner pencil core fell out. Second, application was not smooth at all. It would not glide on to my eye lid. I had to apply a lot of pressure to get it to go on my lid. Also, it was not dark or a smooth line over my lid. This eyeliner is not worth spending the money on. I won't be buying Loreal eye products in the future.