L'Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Pencil Eyeliner with Built in Sharpener, Black

I haven't needed to open the Black/Brown eyeliner yet, but from the former one that I am still using, I really like it. It goes on smoothly without tugging so I feel confident this one will do the same. It also lasts very well; I have not noticed any smudging.

I'm still on the fence with my thoughts about this eyeliner because sometimes it seems as if it's brittle and just wants to break off, or it just bends mm so I'll try it for a little bit longer and see if that improves.

I highly recommend this eyeliner. It always is sharp creating a nice line for your eye lids. It stays on the entire day and does not smudge off. It removes easily at the end of the day with proper makeup remover.

So easy to use! Accurate sharp precision liner and soft application—don't have to pull on eyelid. Stays put, lasts all day. My all time favorite and mainstay liner, I always keep 2 (buy it on sale) to never be without it!

My go-to for eyeliner! I've used this for years and when I try another brand, I come back to this. It stays put, does not cake or feel heavy on the eyelids, it goes on nicely!

I've tried many eyeliners over the years, but I'm so pleased with L'Oreal's Infallible Eye Liner which creates a line as thick or as thin as you want, that I immediately ordered a second one in case L'Oreal decided to discontinue this particular eye liner.

My 81 yo mother who has basically no eyebrows remaining, or are so light they are almost invisible. She uses this pencil with good results, fairly natural looking, says it is easy to use and blend

As an eyeliner pencil, the product is firmer and smears less than others that I have tried. Added bonus is L'Oreal is the only company I have found to make the shade Sable. Not black, not brown. Perfect to work with graying hair and not looking too bold.

I was very disappointed with this product especially because I purchased two. As you use the product you turn bottom and eye pencil crayon moves up, well this product keeps breaking off in pieces. Also, about an hour after wearing it smears under your bottom lashes,nasty. L'Oreal you can do better than this..... I would definitely recommend not buying this product.

I'M going to return this because it seems to be awfully dark and I 'm very light. If I partied often it would be very nice 👍 I gave it the numbers I did because I haven't opened the package to try. It looks like a great product though and I would give it a chance.