L'Oreal Paris Pencil Perfect Self Advancing Eyeliner, Ebony

Equivalent to Clinique!

I expect good results

Love how black and pigmented it is i have the shade carbon black and it also glides on like a dream but...it smudges and fades like its no ones business and dosent stay on the water line (max. it stays on is 1 hour and it dosent look that black after an hour) oh yeah i got mine from ulta and it came broken it wouldnt twist up or down.-.

Hate it will now advance when tip is wore down.

Like many others on this review, gently turning the base to the right to “sharpen” is useless. I have gotten two use of this eyeliner only. I was happy when I initially got the product, but this self advancing “technology” ruins it completely. I was hoping I could find tips on how to advance it on here, but saw the same response, which doesn't work.

unable to get the pencil to advance, does not work with twisting end to advance, i can see pencil inside very disappointed to say the least

This is horrible. It keeps breaking off, doesn't have a pointed end, and basically makes a sloppy line under the eyes.

I bought this and loved it at the start. the actual pencil is great, but the mechanism is horrible. As I used it the Self-Advancing mechanism stopped working. It would turn, but it would not advance. I wanted to give it a second try and the same thing happened again. I will not purchase this again and I cannot recommend this particular eyeliner.

I LOVE L'Oreal and use a lot of their products. I have to say this one is highly disappointing and I will not be purchasing it again. I used the eyeliner three times and love it, it stayed on, went on smoothly, BUT, the eyeliner will not advance. No matter how much I twist the bottom of the pencil, the eyeliner will not come out. I am so very disappointed as I liked the product, but now I feel like I spent too much money on something I was only able to wear three times. I wish I hadn't of thrown the packaging away, I would of taken it back. I hope you solve this problem!

I bought this eyeliner because I liked the grey color. It is easy to apply and I was very happy with it until I found out it won't advance at all - it only turns and turns. Very disappointing and certainly not worth buying if all you get to use is the original tip it comes with.