L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Butterfly Waterproof Mascara, Black, 0.21 fl. oz.

I like the fact that the wand comes separate from the product so it hasn't been sitting in the mascara for months or years. The mascara goes on easily and just a couple of coats with the long side of the brush makes my lashes curl up and look longer. I use the short side to do the lower lashes without making the mess I usually make there. I got my first of this product on special on Amazon. The price then went up before I could order more so I went back to my favorite place, Walmart.

Was delivered to wrong address but Walmart was responsive and made it right

I have thin, wonky, short eyelashes. There aren’t words to describe how frustrated I am that L’Oreal discontinued this mascara. It’s the only one, because of the brush, that I could use and have my eyelashes look decent. I always buy several at a time, and I have one unopened package left. And I’ve tried virtually every other L’Oreal mascara, and they don’t work for me. I can’t have a gigantic brush or a very thin brush, I need the butterfly mascara brush. L’Oreal has lost a customer because they were fools to get rid of this mascara. Tells me they don’t care about their customers. (I’ll eat my words if you can point me to this particular style brush ANYWHERE else on the market.)

PLEASE BRING THIS PRODUCT BACK. So disappointed that it was discontinued. It's the only mascara I had used for over a decade. Now I've had to try 3 others, and they're all terrible! Why discontinue a product that was perfection? You have let down a lot of your customers.

This is literally the best mascara I have ever used, and I’ve been using it for an extremely long time! I’m extremely upset that it has been discontinued. The wand was so effective in spreading my lashes and getting in the creases. Now, my only resort is saving the wand. I have left to see if it fits in another one of their products. PLEASE BRING THIS PRODUCT BACK!

This has been my favorite mascara for probably a decade and the favorite of anyone I ever recommended it to. I’ve never found another mascara I liked nearly as much as this one, I would have bought all the stock I could find had I known it was being discontinued. I won’t be giving loreal any of my money as long as this product remains discontinued.

Why was this mascara discontinued? It was the best. I cannot find anything comparable. I bought another L'Oreal mascara but it does not compare to the butterfly voluminous. I will not buy anymore L'Oreal products for fear if I like them, they would be discontinued as well.

The one star is because I can't find it any longer! After years of trying to find a mascara that worked for me I was so happy to find this one. Have been using it for past 3 years. Only mascara that stayed on my oily lashes and the brush was designed by a genius with the ability to comb and separate the lashes. I actually looked like I had full lashes using this mascara. I'm heartbroken I can't buy it anywhere. Unfortunately other L'Oreal mascaras I've tried aren't even comparable. The new search begins unless L'Oreal brings it back.

I am so disappointed i requesting you bring back the Loreal volumous butterfly mascara. I have used this for years and it is the best as far as I am concerned on the market. I have not found a better product. I have tried other mascaras none match it.

My poor rating is due to the discontinued product only. This is hands down the best mascara. The unique wand design made my lashes look amazing. L'Oréal has countless mascara, with the old school wand. Why remove this product that was the only one in your line. Such a disappointment. I will have to move to a different brand.