L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Extra Volume Collagen Washable Mascara, Blackest Black, 0.34 fl. oz.

The best mascara I used since 2012. I'm so sad that this is discontinued. This was my holy grail mascara and only mascara I used for over 10 years because of how amazing this product was. PLEASE bring this mascara back into production because I cannot for the life of me find any other mascara that compares to this one. It's been a year since my last tube ran out and this is still my all time favorite mascara. Nothing compares. It's a shame this one has been discontinued.

I have been buying this for over 10 years and have put so many people onto this mascara! Please, please do not discontinue this!!! What do I wear now?

I've been using it for over 15 years and today cannot find it anywhere… please please do not discontinue, I have wasted soo much money on other kinds… nothing compares!

PLEASE BRING IT BACK!!!! We've tried other mascaras and NOTHING compares to this. Please do not discontinue

I absolutely LOVE this mascara. Sadly it has been discontinued in the USA.

What was this mascara discontinued?!? It was my favorite and I used to get so many compliments when wearing it.

I've been using this mascara for close to 12 years, I was skeptical when they changed the packaging, but it's forever my #1. I LOVE the applicator, I can't find another one quite the same, and I love how you can just do a second coat if needed. It lasts all day.. and the days when I'm lazy and don't take off my mascara, it fights the battle in my sleep and wins. Not on as much in the morning, but my eyelashes NEVERRR clump with this product

This is by far my favourite mascara ever! I have been using it for years and years and others I try never even compare. I have naturally long lashes, but it still lengthens and adds a lot of volume but isn't too "spidery". I always get compliments on my lashes wearing this! I hope it never gets discontinued because I really don't know what I'd use instead. The only downside for me is that it does transfer to my browbone or lower lash line (not a big deal to me just wipe away with finger, don't use it on lower lashes)

I've been using this for years and I'm so sad you have discontinued it!! Not happy!!

Best mascara by far! I love it, love it, love it! I've used tons of mascara in my 63 years and this one is by far, the best. L'oreal hit it out of the park with this favorite! Please don't discontinue it ever!