Maybelline Define-A-Lash Lengthening Washable Mascara, Very Black

Best waterproof mascara ever made. I'm not sure why Maybelline is not making this anymore. It was the ultimate go to for me for years. Now, I can't find it anywhere! All these companies changing things that work for years, sell well and obviously in high demand makes zero sense to me.

Maybelline's "define-a" line has been awesome so far. I have tried the liner and now the mascara and I have to say I'm highly impressed with this line of definition products so far, the mascara AND the eyeliner both go on very smoothly. For me it's all about how it separates and defines the lashes with mascara because my eyelash for some reason don't separate (maybe it's everyone's but), anyways, this stuff is awesome, I recommend everyone to try it at least once, I don't think you'll be SUPER disappointed if you are at all.

This is the only mascara I'll buy. I've tried others thinking they could be better, they never are. This doesn't clump up like some, the brush is great for applying. You will be happy you purchased this mascara!

This waterproof mascara is perfect for people with dry eye who need to use lubricating drops throughout the day. I can never find this mascara in stores, but thank goodness I can order it online. I've been using it for years. If you apply it slowly, swiping from root to tip, it looks just as good as the tubing mascaras which are not nearly as waterproof.

I'm a very picky mascara girl. I've tried so many of them and I have a system on applying and getting perfect lashes. I really thought this would be a great one, but it's really just an average-some what below average one for me. You can't build on it because it's too stiff and gets clumps throughout. It does not lengthen like it says, and I have tried many lengthening mascaras. Will use it up, but not reorder it.

Product is great, but my order was wrong, ordered 3 water proof and got only one, and two regular non waterproof

The way it goes on feels like the bottle is almost empty—like when you realize you need more mascara!

I never received my item. When I try to initiate a return, it doesn't give me the option of saying, "never received". If I click on "missing item" it wants me to return the remaining items. That's impossible because no other items were delivered with it. When I tried called the store, I get put on hold or automated systems comes up saying to try another time. It's been a week already. Go ahead Walmart, keep the money, you obviously need it more than I do.

I'd been using this mascara for years and was a total fan! Loved it and raved about it. It went on smoothly, cleanly and evenly and gave a subtle, but well defined and I think quite elegant and unfussy look. But something's changed and the last 3 of them I've bought have been awful. I persisted, thinking they were possibly just from bad batches - strong chemical smell and when applied, clumpy and flaky. So different to how the product used to be. I will NOT be buying again. Very disappointed that, of all the mascaras to meddle with, they had to choose this already perfect one!

This is the mascara that I ordered but IT IS NOT THE MASCARA I RECEIVED!!! 😡 So now I have to make a trip to the store to return the wrong one when I was trying to avoidthe trip to the store!!