Maybelline EyeStudio Lasting Drama Gel Liner, Brown

I can't find this original one in shops I've used for yeeears. I bought the new tattoo gel liner and it is awful 😫😭 I'm going to have to search for a new brand for eyeliner

The only liner I use because I have dark brown eyes and need a very black eyeliner to make my eyes stand out. I've tried mac which has better staying power ( without a primer), but Mac is not as black as this liner. I would recommend a primer for all day stay:

the best you can buy and it stays till the next day. making your eyes look bright and ready. I recommend to anyone who don't want to keep checking there eyeliner. it doesn't run.

Best eyeliner I've ever used. Could stay on longer. And after awhile it seems to dry up to where it's not as easy to apply. But it's still the better of what I've tried as of yet.

I was the no.1 recommender for this eyeliner back in the day. Sadly the new formula is not only terrible but it is honestly unusual, gritty, dries on skin in clumps?? Leading it to break away, cannot put it on the waterline anymore. Not smooth or creamy, and even causes irritation. It's unusable. I had never had to rehydrate the old eyeliner, but you can't even hydrate this one. At first it was jusy clumpy?? Hard to get a nice amount on the brush, which was also better in the old eyeliner as it was just a brush and easy to hold, great quality, never dried up either because of the cap and no sponge end which gets annoying. I'm not sure why this eyeliner was ever changed to be honest as I heard nothing but raving reviews and even people thanking me for showing them a gel eyeliner that was beyond great quality that wouldn't break their wallets.

I recently bought the new formula eye liner pot and I don't like it at all . It's very dry and very hard to blend . I much prefer the old version. I will never buy it again . It's west of my money and I am so disappointed

I have used this eyeliner for years and loved it but the new formula is awful! Dry and impossible to apply, such a shame as it was a fantastic product, will not be buying again.

I love this product. My review is not of the product, it's related to the shipper. What is shown is NOT what was sent. I wanted this specific product not what replaced it. Pictures need to be updated to the actual product you will be receiving not what is pictured.

when I open the packaging the lid fell off because it wasn't screwed on some idiot machine at the factory hasn't been sealing the lids and I know this because I have bought four of these in the last two weeks from different retailers and every single one of them has been dried out because the lid isn't sealed I had to return this one because it was so dried out it was cracked down the middle

If I could give 0 stars Why change the formula I've been using this for years, I have to bin the new formula waste of money it's unusable can't even get it on the brush, now I have to for another one