Maybelline EyeStudio Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner Makeup, Black, 2 Pack

This is the one I always come back to. Sometimes I try other waterproof volumizing mascaras (Loreal Lash Paradise was my last try - ner!), but I always come back to The Falsies. Thickens and doesn't dry out as fast as other wp mascaras. It's a win.

This eyeliner is perfect. I can make a full line without having to touch up. It doesn't run or smudge unless I intend to smudge. I've been using Tattoo for years. I buy several at a time so I won't run out.

I've worn this mascara since late 70's as well as their regular (non waterproof) mascara and it has never failed. This waterproof mascara holds up while swimming, sunbathing and bawling my eyes out crying. It takes some effort to remove but using a specific makeup remover cream works well. It's an all day mascara and doesn't leave raccoon eyes in the morning if you sleep with it on. Trusted by me for… well, almost forever.

This is one of my favorite mascaras. It makes eyelashes look long and full. It also stays put all day without flaking. Even swimming or getting rained on doesn't smudge it. And when you're ready, it washes off easily with some soap and water or makeup remover.

I never tried the liquid eyeliner before bought this. It works pretty good. I don't wear makeup as much anymore because of my allergies and I'm always rubbing my eyes, but this seems like it stays on a lot better and don't smudge or nothing and it's super easy to go on it just Clydes on, but if you do get it in your eye, it burns a lot

This used to be my favorite mascara. I've used it for years. They recently changed the formula and good luck trying to remove it from your eyelashes. You will need to soak them in make up remover forever. It's unfortunate because this stuff used to remind me a lot of a very expensive tubing mascara. Not any more.

This is my favorite mascara but for some reason it seems like the amount inside the container is getting less and less. I'm having to purchase it faster then before, I use the same amount as always. it usually lasts me 3 to 4months, now I'm having to buy it in 2 months, ps: it also is trying up faster.

This used to be my go to for years and i don't know what they did but the transfer and smearing makes it unwearable. I've never had issues with any mascara transferring. I looked in the mirror after wearing for 1 hour and was shocked. Tried again with powder around eyes, a few more times, and a final time using lash primer first. Smears so bad every time. I guess i'll return it or eat the cost.

Package received was not the Waterproof mascara. Sadly discovered from crying after death of close family member pulled it out of drawer until I was in a rush out the door to A family gathering after a death %26 of bjust finished my prior mascara %26 pulled this new purchase out %26used it in a rush out the door only to discover of all times after a death in the family

Worst mascara I've ever used. I usually use the sky high one in the pink tube. This one was not even noticeable even when I used two coats. Couldn't be more disappointed. Oh, and it doesn't come off when you try to wash your face. It's not waterproof, it shouldn't act waterproof.