Milani Stay Put Infinite Eyeliner , Black

This is the only liner I use. The prior formula before it was temporarily discontinued was better and longer lasting but this current still out performs anything I've tried in the market.

The quality of this eyeliner is great not to watery

Milani is my all time favourite. I just love Milani.

I usually use MAC eyeliners. This Milani eyeliner is even better. I'm so happy that they brought it back. Even tho the price went up it's still affordable.

If you are looking for a liner that doesn't smudge or budge, this is it. I have very watery eyes, and the liner stays put. I was very impressed with its overall longevity. I suspect it would be great for cat eyes, but that is not my style. The down side for me was that it dries very quickly, so if you make a mistake putting it on, it is very hard to correct without having to use remover and start over. At first I had trouble adjusting to the brush. It puts it on on a little too thick for me, but I am getting used to working with the brush to get a thinner line. With all of that said, the fact that it lasts forever and does not smear, and looks the same after 12 hours, makes it a great liner, and I definitely recommend it.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This is a very good liquid liner in a number of ways: It almost always stays smooth and doesn't “crack” even if you leave it on overnight. Also even though it's waterproof, it isn't hellacious to remove with makeup remover pads. It comes off rather cleanly. Being a long time lover and user of liquid liner, I was disheartened when my favorite go to from another makeup brand was discontinued. I was happy to see Milani offering a liquid liner! I am very adept at using liquid liner and the only cons with this liner is it's a little almost gloppy to work with so you have to be very careful to have a neat line and the liner brush part isn't flexible enough. But once you get a nice line it is unexpectedly resilient and pretty in that I like the tone and shininess of the color. I give it a thumbs up overall.

Formula is alil different from the everlast which i personally love ,this new formula i feel like it was actually harder to apply it with the "Improved" wand, i did however like the matte finish to it.

Not a good product the liquid liner does not paint or stick well and the felt bstick or brush does nothing to help it even be applied on your eyes.

Ever since they discontinued my Maybelline eyeliner I've been on the search for another one that has a brush tip and not a stupid felt tip. I'm also looking for an eyeliner that stays put and does not smudge. This eyeliner is not that! After an hour of wearing it, it smudged all over the top of my eyelids and looked horrible! But on the flipside when you go to take it off at night, it doesn't not come off all the way no matter how hard you scrub your eyes!! I will not be buying this again!! Beware if you have oily skin, it will smudge all over as the day goes by! just a warning

smelled like motor oil smudged badly