Milani Stay Put Matte Eyeliner, Black Waterproof

This eyeliner s wonderful. It's long lasting, delivered on time, exactly as described, well packaged and nd I love it. Ladies get some today, you'll be glad you did. Thank you.

I have been using this eyeliner for YEARS! It's extremely pigmented, lasts all day and has a matte finish.

This is the worst eyeliner I've ever used. Did not set or dry. Is not waterproof AT ALL. The regular 17hr is much better and I will go back to that as this product was a huge disappointment. Would NOT recommend.

I love Milani. I just need a truly waterproof eyeliner and she can't do what I need. Im also older so the felt tip didn't help but for a younger person this would probably work. It is a very good color. If only it stayed as well as I had hoped.

my favorite have been using this brand for more than 4 years love it😍

To little product for the price .. doesn't go very far i would rather pay more and get more product so i dont have to keep ordering.

I have tried so many liquid eyeliners.. this one is the worst eyeliner I have ever tried. The tip is horrible not even like a brush or a felt tip like described it's like a rounded rubber tip??? You do not get that “sharp” look this is horrendous, I wish I could give zero stars since there's nothing good about it. DO NOT BUY

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Does go on as smooth as I'd like but it's better than Elf.

I loved the applicator and it went on smooth and easy to control but it is not waterproof or even water resistant. It smudged so easily so the title of waterproof was misleading.

Was looking to find a replacement for the discontinued Infinite 24 hour liquid liner and this didn't even come close. I have oily lids and smudges/rubs off in the middle of the day. Even tried an eyelid primer, powder, applying the liner, and more powder. I also tried the non-waterproof version and didn't notice a difference between the two. Stayed better than The Tank liner from Milani. Please bring back the Infinite 24 Hour liquid liner! Only thing that stays put.