Milani Stay Put Mechanical Eyeliner in After Dark

Milani is my favorite but it is difficult to find anyone that carries it. But Walmart did so I am happy about that. Price was good but I always want to pay less, hence the 4 stars.

I'm not much of a makeup person anymore, however, Milani is the only thing that I'm not allergic to. It is an All-Day wear, with minimal smudge. Drawing a straight line depends on the operator. I don't think it makes you look like you have oily eyelids, but everything with always have complaints. I love Milani!

this is hands down the best drugstore eyeliner. is not on the soft and creamy but stays on until you take it off without smearing. The only drugstore liner I've ever found that works as good as it does. Great buy. highly recommended.

Excellent Waterline Eyeliner. This is an intense color for your eyes. I have dark brown/black eyes and this definitely brings out them out. It stays put and does not budge by end of day.

Nice lastly smooth line that last all day. Thank you

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I haven't been able to find the Duchess shade in any stores, so, I ordered online. It's a smoky purple shade that is highly complementary to brown and green eyes. I use it on my lower lash line for a nice pop of color to my eyes. It glides on so smoothly and truly does not budge. Wore it for about 10 hours and it didn't smudge or fade. Love it!

This is absolutely the BEST eyeliner pencil. It goes on smoothly and never flakes or smears. It stays on - even when playing tennis in the FL heat! It is a staple of my makeup routine every day! The color is really beautiful, too.

Goes on smooth and easy. However, if I'm not cautious throughout the day, the liner goops in the corners of my eyes and bleeds down under my bottom liner => raccoon eyes. Easy to maintain as long as I don't let it go too long. Sure wish I could find a liner that I don't have to constantly fool with and worry about.

Nice creamy stay put eyeliner, however the Duchess Purple color was disappointing.... not purple and not vibrant as shown...more muddy brown in color. Great product, not a great color.

Not happy with color black turns blue