Neutrogena Hydro Boost Plumping Mascara, Black/Brown 03,.21 oz

My daughter and I love this mascara. it is clean, waterproof, and doeant flake.

I have very sensitive dry eyes. This mascara stays on, doesn't clump, and with eye makeup remover; it comes off very easy. No stress to my eyes! Awesome!

I really enjoyed the thickening aspects of this mascara, but it took a while to dry down....and can get on eyelids due to how wet it is. After having opening it and having a couple of weeks go by, that is less of an issue. It does stay on in the most humid conditions, but it can flake a bit too. A bit more of a struggle to remove, but that's the case for all waterproof mascars. I think it is a great waterproof mascara for the price point.

I was very disappointed with this product. Shame on Neutrogena. My lashes didn't look longer and within 2 weeks the product was so dry and clumpy that it barely worked at all any more. I ended up throwing it away and buying another product.

It burned my eyes when I applied it so I cannot use it. It does clump some too.

I thought that I would try this different waterproof mascara as I have used Mabelline for ever. I can go to bed with it on and sweat and do not have any smudges. I just got out of the tub and have smudges under my eyes. I guess I will stick to my Mabelline waterproof.

This mascara did not work out as well for me as i had hoped. I have another kind of Neutrogena mascara (the name escapes me right now) that I love. I will be ordering it soon. This may work for others, but on me, it was clumpy. I guess my eyelashes didn't like being plumped.

Item damaged and I have to return it

I had to stop work, go to the restroom and wash this stuff off. My eyes burned and teared for a while even after I washed it off. Definitely not for me.

I hated this mascara. It was sticky. My made lashes look like spider legs and they would cling together when I shut my eyes. Looked like I was wearing 10 year old mascara that I added baby oil to. I will stick to Healthy Lash. I love almost all of Neutrogena's products. But not this one.