New Day Apple Butter Pumpkin Pie

I am a pumpkin flavor fanatic. I love food %26 drinks that are flavored with a good pumpkin flavor. I thought I would try this because I also love apple butter, but I was skeptical about how the two would go together. It is absolutely delicious!!! I was really pleasantly surprised. At first, you get that apple butter flavor, but then the pumpkin comes in and they blend together perfectly. And I love the oatmeal crunch on top, too. We will be getting this again!

This pie is SO GOOD! I know I should have waited for Thanksgiving but I didn't and I regret nothing. It's the perfect amount of pumpkin pie and dutch apple pie all in the same pie. I wish they had this product year-round because it's delicious and a perfect dessert.

Tastes good. I'm not sure what else to say but I did like it.

The taste of this pie was okay. It has a really strong cinnamon flavor. I would like it a lot better if the cinnamon was toned down.

Too much topping, not enough filling. Difficult to cut, the "crust on top" crumbles while trying to cut. The topping and the filling is so sweet, the flavor of the filling is just sweet with neither pumpkin or apple butter flavors coming through. The topping is not evenly distributed, but piled up in one area that has pressed the "filling" into a less than 1/4 inch layer. The bottom crust is so tough, it is difficult to cut, even with a sharp knife. For me this is inedible so is going straight into the trash. I'm sorry I wasted my money on it.

crumb topping was so-so .. filling was okay .. bottom crust was bad. It was very pale .. no flavor .. wet .. not a good crust at all. Was excited when I saw it available - but very disappointed when I tasted it. Would not buy again.

sounded awesome. had to double check that I wasn't supposed to bake it first because it tastes like raw pumpkin with waaay too much "seasoning"(i love cinnamon but I have found one type that is nasty bitter strong and that's what this tastes like) I disagree about"too sweet" reviews, it tastes like they forgot all sweeteners altogether, coupled with not cooking the pumpkin. there's a good balance of filling to topping in mine, but every bite I tried, hoping I just had a badly mixed patch, it just built up more bitter raw pumpkin and bad cinnamon flavor. the regular pumpkin pies I got (different brand) also don't taste great this year but not in the same way so I don't think it's a me problem. I can't help but keep thinking it never got cooked because raw pumpkin is also more bitter. if it was all seasoning it would be more brown, not so orange and runny.

Pie smells like rotten spoiled milk

Taste band

I don't know if I got a bad one or what but..gross!! It was soooo salty it tastes like someone used salt in place of sugar. I tasted each part separately trying to figure out what I was tasting and it was the filling that tasted like pure salt. So disappointed, I'm just glad I didn't serve it to anyone else.