N.Y.C. New York Color City Proof 24 Hr Eye Shadow,

I have two colors: blue and grey. On eye they are little different (blue is more of sea color, grey is really grey whitout bit of brown), but solid, full of pigment. Price is right. I regret there are only 5 colors. I'm not master of mak-up and application is easy - big plus for me. "THE STICK OF EYESHADOW LOVES TO FALL OUT" That's so true!

I didnt think much of NYC becuase I assumed it was "cheap dime-store brand make-up". But I found a color that I like, so I figured it was only $3 lost if I didnt like it. Well....I Love it! It has just the right amount of pigment and the color stays ALL DAY! At night, I actually have to wash it off otherwise I think it would still be there when I woke up. CERTAINLY worth the $3 I spent. My only complaint is now that I like it so much, I cannot find anywhere else to buy different colors.

I use this product on my eyebrows as an eyebrow pencil. Works great and I love it!

I really love this product for the wear and long lasting. I hate the fact that all of the sticks that I have bought have broken. This goes from 5 stars to 1.

I have four of these little puppies, and I cannot say that I adore them, nor can I say that I hate them. I like them, for their price they are well worth it. They blend easily and are very pigmented. I use mine on a daily basis, however there is ONE Thing keeping me from giving it that last star. THE STICK OF EYESHADOW LOVES TO FALL OUT. On all four of mine I am constantly putting the shadow back into its tube. It's a good thing it has the cap or I would have lost the shadow long ago. I have no idea if there is a way to fix it or not but it's not going to stop me from continuing to buy them.

I bought the taupe color a couple of weeks ago thinking that it was worth a shot. Turns out that this is easy to apply and super pigmented. You hardly need a primer but this does come with one. I want to try more colors the only issue I had was that the crayon was trying to fall out but I can't tell if that's how I handled it or if it was my dumb luck

I received this product in a for-review type box and gave it a try. I love how smooth it glides on, and the color is great (Brooklyn Mocha). It blends well and definitely lasts. The main concern I have is that after just a couple of uses the product began to fall out of the container, and if it didn't have the lid I would have lost it completely. And now it is loose when I'm trying to apply it. After reading other reviews I see that this is a common problem. Not a deal breaker for me, but something that could definitely be improved if possible.

I love the look of NYC City Proof 24 HR Eye Shadow, however after just a few uses the center of the pencil came out. I hadn't even sharpened it yet.

The pencil was a pretty color, but it was so dry. It would not even go on my eyelids. I tried several times to use it, but ended up returning.

The shadow came out of the stick after using only twice. Can't use it now. Glad I didn't spend much money on this. You get what you pay for clearly.....