NYX Cosmetics Collection Noir Glossy Black Liner 0.25g/0.01oz

I don't remember when I bought the retractable eyeliner. It's easy to use and smudges really well. I am 60 and am using makeup age appropriate. I have seen some women of my age who do go overboard. (oh boy.)

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I bought this Skinny liner a while back to try in a local store and liked it so well went to the website and ordered 2 more. Eyeliner never stays with me all day and this product does, I was sold. Love the thin line with this liner.

This is my 3rd bottle and I never thought I'd find an eyeliner product that is just so easy to use, doesn't smear and doesn't look harsh - all in one! As all the NYX I've purchased in the last couple of years, this is a stand out as well.

I am loyal to this liner. Easy to use, inky black, great coverage. It has a long skinny brush, which is my favorite for liquid liners. Add a bit of primer to your lids first and this liner will stay put a day.

I bought this two weeks ago and I love how it frames my eyelids. It has the precise point of liquid eyeliner. The mechanics could be better retracting the liner tip in and out.

The LIQUID BLACK LINER is AMAZING! I have super greasy eyelids/face and I put NYX eyeshadow primer on then this eyeliner and it stayed ALL DAY! Normally it would be faded or halfway down my face but nope! If you are looking for a super black liquid liner that will stay all day, you have to try this!

Buy 6 at-a-time. This is my thrid time purchasing.

Product came in the mail much faster than I expected. The packaging is to cute and keeps everything nice and safe :) the eyeliner pencil however, seems to need some work. At first it glides on smoothly and effortlessly but after you sharpen it, everything falls apart.

I bought this wanting to try another eye pencil to line my waterline but it does a horrible job. It smears not that long after I apply it. I'm so disappointed I wanted it to work. Not worth the money at all!!! There are liners that are cheaper and do a much better job than this.

The Kohl Kajal liner pencil is the worst pencil I have ever used. It did not effortlessly line my eye but dragged and was painful. Also the color wasn't true and was gone a few hours after I put it on. I tried with primer but it wasn't much better. All in all it was a complete waste of money. NYX carries a retractable pencil and a jumbo eye crayon that are superior. I am going back to those.