NYX Cosmetics Gel Liner and Smudger Charlotte (Brown)

I Apply Thin Or Thick...I Like The Dramatic Look...Has Intense Color Payoff....Great For Quick application For On The Go, But Fun To Play With When I'm In A Creative mood Another one of my must haves!!!

I'm always looking for a smooth, jet black eyeliner that stays the course and doesn't move. This is it! I find it works best on my upper lash and wing. If I am going for a more dramatic or darker look, I'll apply just under the water line and use a pencil for the waterline. Perhaps I'm impatient for the waterline to dry, but it never ends well when I apply a gel or liquid there. I very much enjoy this gel liner and if anyone has a brush suggestion for the most magical wings with this stuff, we can be best friends.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the quality and I love everything about it it's easy to add on it's not chunky like other ones that I've bought from different brands

I love this liner! It goes on easy and stays put. I wore it all day and didn't have to reapply. And the color was a perfect black. I will definitely buy this again and again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this gel liner. I got the brown color and is really dark and applies smoothly. Lasts me all day without moving around

Bought this eyeliner because my Slim Marker dried out on me- and this one is much better! It applies so smoothly, and it doesn't take much to get a great line! I don't use it as a smudger, so I have no idea how that works. First gel eyeliner I've tried and I love it! The only thing I dislike is how it seems to transfer to my upper eyelid if it's even a little oily.

I was a little taken aback when I seen the size of it, but then I used it and understood. This product goes a long way. You need very little and it goes on so smoothly. The colour is such a nice intense black. I think this has to be one of the best black eyeliners I have ever used. However, I did not realize when ordering that it was waterproof(my fault), and when they say waterproof they mean it. Even with makeup removers I still have to go over it again to get it all off. Not necessarily a bad thing though.

Great gel liner. After one layer it's opaque enough where multiple layers aren't needed to achieve pitch black. Other brands I've tried are much too sheer. This liner provides the look of a liquid but with better staying power and no flaking. I find it easier to apply than liquid liner too - just need a good angle brush to dab or feather it on. Great for doing cat eye/wings!

I bought this in blue and I love the shade! Unfortunately it's really sheer... Like, in an oily way that you can't really build on. I was hoping to do a chunky blue eyeliner/wing with a neutral shadow, but I think I'd have to go over it with a matching blue shadow to actually make it pop at all. Kind of defeats the purpose of blue eyeliner, right? It doesn't seem like it would smudge out properly, either. I can't speak to staying power, (Or to the quality of the black) because I haven't worn it out for a night yet.

I bought this hoping it would be the perfect blue eyeliner! ! It's not pigmented at all and when applying with a brush it just smears around everywhere..