NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo All-in-One Eye Shadow and Eye Pencil Makeup, Milk

I saw this in black and decided to give it a try. I needed black eyeliner/shadow/whatever for around my eyes and on my face for my plague doctor outfit for Halloween. I usually just use cheap eye shadow, but it doesn't last long and rubs off too easily. This pencil is fantastic. It went on smoothly and easily (I didn't even need to blend it) and it washed off slightly less easy (I used makeup remover to get it all off). But it is fantastic and it did exactly what I hoped it would do.

I recently bought this jumbo stick. And let me tell you its AMAZING! perfect for a pop of color and makes eyeshadow intense. I truly recommend this:) Araceli!

It does its job to give more highlight in my eye area. I do have a dark dark brown eyes which is almost black and it totally enhance the shape of my eyes.

Bought it last month. And it does wonders, it stay the whole day. Color don't run down that fast and it is highly recommended for all.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] OMG love these jumbo eye pencil especially the blue one, I am definitely ordering me some more and i definitely love the size to .

This stuff is awesome very creamy and the color is so stunning.

I wish they made it more clear on here, or on packaging. It is not a “twist” even though the bottom is plastic, there’s a ton of more makeup - INSIDE. I got a really cheap jumbo makeup pencil sharpener online that came in 2 days for it. It does have a tiny cap on the sharpener you’ll need to take off to fit (I know sounds like a butt, but SO easy) I was confused for a bit, I was like surely it has more in it than this until I saw a review saying what to do lol on the actual makeup part though- this is my favorite. I’ve probably tried I dunno 100? Maybe highlights from doing cosmetology, and loving makeup for forever. This one works for me personally (different for everyone obviously) I have oily skin, but can get a dry nose in winter/ if I do a peel mask. This is the only one that doesn’t look like my makeup is separating or coming off. I put some on the tops of checks, under my eyebrow, and nose. Usually where I can see light is hitting naturally. It is very moveable. If you are planning on putting it on your eyelids too- I would steer clear of that idea, for this product if your eyelids are oily like mine. It will crease. Also I put a little in my lower inner eye to make me look more awake lol. ANYWAY highly recommend, just takes a sec to sharpen it once in awhile. BTW it will sound like plastic%26 you might be confused when you sharpen it, but it is pushing up product! :) good luck with your makeup :) Also last thought- I don’t put much product out in case it does break off somehow so I don’t lose any of the product.

I bought the milk color for primer and inner eye brightening and was initially disappointed that it seemed I could only use the tip of the pencil and wouldn't last long. I have a double NARS sharpener and tried it on the bigger side and it worked! It all looks plastic so I didn't think it would work but it did. Just wanted to let everyone know because I was extremely frustrated too. As for the milk color it does work great as a primer IMO.

The makeup itself is good but it’s impossible to sharpen it even with a big sharper. You can either, only use the visible tip seen or find a knife a try to cut away the plastic edge to get more product that’s otherwise useless. Wasteful and bad designed product.

The pencil will not advance (roll up) very small amount of product for the money.