NYX Professional Makeup Retractable Eye Liner, Black

I bought this eyeliner last year first time and than when price down I stocked. This time I bought 3 different colour and 20 liners . I love it my fewer black and brown . And lip liner I used this picture Nyx lipliner

Amazing look on the bottom of my eyes as well as shipped faster than I thought!

It was love at first use! I love the easy application as well as the long wear. Waterproof isn't bad either! I use the midnight blue and with my eye color I really make a statement!!! Have re-ordered numerous times and hope to do so in the future, as long as you still carry the product! That's why I buy 6 or so at a time. Love it! Thanks

I used to purchase the retractable eyeliners from MAC. They were over priced and I kept trying eyeliners until I stumbled across NYX. I love there black and brown eyeliners. Beats MACs prices any day for the same quality.

I love the retractable eyeliner in bronze because its great for everyday use and lasts long. The amount of product is perfect for the price and the color is simply goregeous.

Color right, retractable color means no grinding away large parts of the liner in a pencil sharpener.. Keeping a point is still hard, even with the retractable feature, meaning that in even in this form much of what you pay for and love is lost. But the color is great, it last well, is is as creamy and spreadable as advertised, And pretty much as lasting s one could hope! use it as lid-shadow as well (finger-work helps keep the point sharp) and order these 5 at a time to use the free shipping --meaning I get almost another pencll ffor what I would be spending for shipping. I plan to use this as long as it is available. Oh, and the 4 rating is because it will not --probaby cannot--keep a point.--but better than most!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The color was good, but the it's not as retractable as the name suggests. It's actually kind of difficult to extend the pen.

Purchased black, got..... not black? The black kinda navy/grey? When I order black, I want true black. Will be returning.

Liner was not working and I tried to roll and take out some to apply but it wasn't going back and further it came out more and my point broke

I was under the impression the eyeliner would be more opaque. I bought the white shade but when I used it, it looked more like crayon than anything else. It kept getting stuck on my skin instead of really gliding and no matter how many times I went over it to make it stand out more, it wouldn't get any brighter.