NYX Professional Makeup Vivid Matte Liquid Liner, Smear-Resistant Eyeliner with Precise Tip, Black

I've waited YEARS to get this eyeliner again. YEARS. I religiously used nyx liquid vinyl eyeliner EVERYDAY for at least 5 years when it was discontinued. I was literally heart broken. NYX commented on a tiktok Mikayla Nogueria posted when it was first discontinued saying it would be back, but as time passed and nothing happened I figured it would never return. I spent months trying to find a similar eyeliner but nothing compared. I managed to snag a few extras that I finally ran out of this year I started that journey again, and again was disappointed I couldn't find anything similar. I settled for nyx epic wear but I absolutely hate it with a passion. So, when Mikayla Nogueria posted a tiktok reviewing the nyx matte liquid liner earlier this month I IMMEDIATELY ordered 5. Though I wish the liquid vinyl was brought back, I'm happy to have the matte one! I've searched high and low and I've hated every eyeliner I tried, this is my all time favorite eyeliner. It's been the only eyeliner that is liquid enough to make a SHARP wing, doesn't smear everywhere, is a true black, and affordable to top it off! Long story short, I recommend.

They finally brought back the Matte liner!! I've been waiting a year!! I was not disappointed. Wears great. Same brush as before. Requires a little skill to work but it's my favorite liner of all time.

This used to be my absolute favorite eyeliner. Been using it for years now. Unfortunately the past 3 I've gotten from Walmart were all bone dry and the felt tip is splitting. I went ahead and ordered from Amazon and the same situation happened. Tried contacting NYX to resolve the issue with no success.

I was a huge fan of the original matte liquid liner from NYX and was really excited (and nervous) about them reformulating it. It goes on super black which I like but it picks up my eyeshadow and turns gray throughout the day. Not the mention it is SUPER CRUMBLY! It picks up all the texture in my lids and clumps up like a cheap mascara. Super disappointing.

Really terrible. after a few uses it dries out and is basically unusable. i try shaking it over and over and northing. complete waste of money. I used their vinyl liquid liner for years and after its discontinuation ive tried a couple other ones from nyx and they all suck.

I mistakenly picked this up when I needed a new line because mine was nearly done. I naively did not check what type of tip it had. I mistakenly had thought professional brands had moved on from brush tips...and Oh my Lord was it an awful, cheap brush. Does anybody like brush tips anymore? the brush didn't come to an easy point and was horrible and difficult to maneuver. The strands wouldnt to stay together.I'm not going to be able to freehand with this. I'll try the old business card trick

If I could give this no starts I would. I opened the box and opened the produce and it was dry. I not liquid in it. Everything else I bought worked good my liquid lipstick was perfect my mascara is the best but this eyeliner was awful because it had no liquid in it. So disappointing. I couldn't believe it lol the brush was all dry

I ordered 3 of these and they all came back as chunky and dried up. I had previously ordered 3 others and they came the EXACT same way! So I thought by ordering more it would prove that those were a one time deal but nope. This just seems to be a fault product

This is the 5th time I've bought this product and it has been completely empty of eyeliner. I've bought from Amazon, and Walmart both. I've lost $$. Fix this issue NYX! I know it's not the first time you've heard this!

When I received, it was all dried up. Couldn't even use it once. Waste of money.