Excellent for the waterlineI have this in whiteout, aqua force, and black onyx. White out and black onyx are phenomenal in the waterline. I have very sensitive/watery eyes and they don't bother me at all and are very pigmented. My only complaint is that aqua force is not very pigmented in the waterline. It works well on the lid, but is very sheer on the waterline. Other than that I love that they are comfortable to wear and don't smear all over the place. I have recommended them to quite a few friends. Oh and to sharpen them without breaking as easily I stick them in the freezer for a little while to harden them some and then use my regular liner sharpener.