Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz price history and forecast - Reese's 58735
Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz

Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz

Brand:
Reese's
Model Number:
58735
UPC:
034000004409
EAN:
0034000004409
ASIN:
B0014CUFBM
Walmart SKU:
38253425
Key Takeaway

Recent downward movement established $1.82 pricing, now 0.0% below the quarterly average.

Third-Party Seller Summary

Third-Party Seller Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$10.00
Lowest Price
$0.88
Most Recent Price
$4.09
Average Price
$2.18
First Tracked
Last Update

Walmart.com Summary

Walmart.com Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$1.82
Lowest Price
$1.32
Most Recent Price
$1.82
Average Price
$1.62
First Tracked
Last Update

Price Analysis

Tracking History: We have tracked Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz since 11/13/2024. The most recent price update was on Sep 2, 2026.

Price Range: Over the past 90 days, the price has ranged from $1.32 (lowest on 11/13/2024) to $1.82 (highest on 10/3/2025). The average price during this period is $1.62.

Current Trend: Walmart.com prices have ranged from $1.82 (Sep 2) to $1.82 (Sep 2) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $1.82.

Customer Insights: Rated 4.7/5 from 7565 reviews.

Customer Reviews

7565 reviews

Customer Reviews

4.7
Based on 7565 reviews
5
6518
4
586
3
179
2
71
1
211
Filter Reviews:
Sort By:
Showing 10 of 7565 reviews

I love my Reeses

Krista June 14, 2026

I'm a chubby chick of course I love chocolate, add peanut butter and I'm in love. BUT Reese like all chocolate is getting to bougie for my broke budget!

Was this review helpful?

disappointed want a refund

anonymous May 22, 2026

if they didnt have the reese i wanted i put a substitution in for the minatures reese im highly upset i spent almot 7 dollars for 4 individual packs ...can i have a refund please

Was this review helpful?

It's Still A Reese Peanut Butter Cup!

DebbieM December 12, 2025

Another one of those products that has not changed their recipe nor practiced "shrink-flation". It's the same quality, flavor and great mix of peanut butter and chocolate as it always has been. I am one of those types of people that would rather pay more than have a company shrink a product or change the recipe.

Was this review helpful?

“Chocolate Candy” BUYER BEWARE! AWFUL QUALITY!

katelyyyn August 8, 2026

Recently, Reese's has changed some of its seasonal products from milk chocolate and peanut butter to “chocolate candy” with “peanut butter crème.” Beware! There's a marked difference in quality. The “chocolate candy” eggs taste oily and cheap, with no chocolate flavor. This stuff tastes like if ChatGPT made candy. I bought a bag of these eggs and I feel absolutely swindled. I expect a certain quality and flavor profile from Reese's products, otherwise I'd buy the no-name seasonal candy on the bottom shelf. No wonder y'all are using Inlfuenster to juice up your reviews.

Was this review helpful?

New formula is awful

LauraMC October 26, 2026

We aren't stupid. We can taste the difference from your cheap substitutions. The chocolate is now waxy and doesn't taste like real chocolate anymore. So disappointing! I was hoping the change was only in the novelty products, but nope, you ruined the classic ones too. Boo.

Was this review helpful?
Ken June 14, 2026

For the price and the size I dont think its worth it, it taste different then the original not as good.

Was this review helpful?
Debra July 15, 2026

Love them so much more than they needed to be thank you

Was this review helpful?

Reeses pricing

MHill July 7, 2026

The cost of these has just hone up and up they are getting too expensive to purchase.

Was this review helpful?
Bobby June 24, 2026

highly recommended taste very good

Was this review helpful?

No High Fructose Corn Syrup!

Ranchhand July 6, 2026

These peanut butter cups are great and made with sugar, not corn syrup or high fructose corn syrup.

Was this review helpful?

Price History

Historical price data graph for Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz

Recent Price Changes

Detailed price history for the past 90 days

Walmart.com Pricing

2 records

Walmart.com prices have ranged from $1.82 (Sep 2) to $1.82 (Sep 2) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $1.82.

Walmart.com price history for Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz showing recent price changes over the past 90 days
Date Price Change % Change
$1.82 $+0.00 +0.0%
$1.82 — —

Third-Party Seller Pricing

14 records

Third-Party Sellers prices have ranged from $1.79 (Oct 14) to $10.00 (Oct 9) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $4.31.

Third-party seller price history for Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Candy, Pack 1.5 oz showing recent price changes
Date Price Change % Change
$4.09 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.09 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.09 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.09 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.09 $+1.60 +64.3%
$2.49 $-1.60 -39.1%
$4.09 $+1.60 +64.3%
$2.49 $-1.60 -39.1%
$4.09 $+1.60 +64.3%
$2.49 $+0.00 +0.0%
$2.49 $+0.70 +39.1%
$1.79 $-8.21 -82.1%
$10.00 $+0.00 +0.0%
$10.00 — —

Related Products