Reese's PB&J Snack Size, 39 Ounce

These weren’t too bad. I had my reservations but since I love the candy and PB&J sandwiches, I thought why not?! I preferred the grape ones the most because you can really taste the flavor. My fiancé loved the strawberry flavor more. It’s worth a try.

I first bought these from BJ’s . Tried ordering them from Walmart. They didn’t seem fresh. The chocolate didn’t have the same taste as the first time I had it.

Im sure that they're usually good but the package I received was nearly 5 months past the Best By date of 12/2025

How would I know. All I got was a gooey bag of melted crud, after 4 days of consecutive out for delivery and then no delivery!

These caught my eye and the picture on the package looked enticing, so I grabbed a bag. But I was very disappointed. These Reese's PB&J cups have a very artificial and off taste, which was surprising as I could barely see any of the so called jam / jelly inside them. I find the grape had more of an off taste than the strawberry Really not impressed, some things are best left as a classic.

They tasted gross and the texture was weird which i thought was the 'jelly' in it. I ordered these 4/2026 but they expired 12/2025. Would not recommend that anyone order these.

Received product 2 pounds of crushed smashed chocolate PB%26J cups, Packaging was terrible. I ordered a mega cereal and they stacked the chocolate on the bottom, then put the other package of chocolate on top of the first one and then put the mega box of cereal and push down on it so that the box of cereal had bent and creased corners. You can imagine what the Reese‘s peanut butter cups looked like.

This product is shipped from Florida. I live in West Virginia. I’m a senior citizen but little money. This was $23. I bought it from my husband who just broke his back. I can’t return his door. I don’t drive. I might as well just put this in the trash, another wasted item from Walmart.

These were already outdated and the taste was not good and they were dry and crumbly. I ended up throwing the bag away.

I guess the strawberry ones aren’t the worst but the grape ones are truly foul. I tried eating them normally and then I also tried eating them frozen no matter what I did. They were just terrible.