I purchased it as it was on sale, and I loved the transparency and the drawing on the liner. I bought it for two refrigerators: in one, the liner is already in place.
The low rating is due to a design flaw: the edges are not a straight 90-degree angle. So if you, like me, assumed it would be straight: a lot of adjustments to correct the 'somewhat of a diamond shape' on the refrigerator's shelf. This required a significant adjustment to fit correctly on the refrigerator shelves.
The transparent liner has a mild dot texture that is only visible at a certain angle, making it challenging to align and to cut accurately. By the end of the first two rolls, I noticed that if I unrolled the liner completely and started cutting from the inner edge of the roll, the entire process would be much quicker and less painful.
My only hope for this (third) roll is that it has a straight, standard 90-degree edge to begin with, which would make the installation much easier.