Secret Wide Solid Antiperspirant Deodorant Powdered Fresh 2.7 oz, 4-Pack

Came in a 2-pack, which was perfect for us. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Love it

I have been using this product forever. The secret solid. I can smell that it is different. It's like the invisiable solid. Which does not work good for me. Like the other review I still have an old one that I'm clutching to. I thought it was just me but I'm glad I saw someone else thinks the same thing

I don't know whose brilliant idea it was to change the way that the powder fresh scent smells without putting a disclosure on the package, but it's just awful! Been using this for decades - no more! I bought a bunch of them and have to throw them away because I can't tolerate the smell. Ewwww!

This deodorant is bad. I used to use Secret when I was in middle school but switched over to Dove several years ago. I decided to try out secret again, specifically this deodorant in the shower fresh scent. The smell was decent, not anything spectacular. I wore this deodorant while I was taking my SAT test and I don't think I have ever sweat more than I did during that test, and it was cold in the room! I still stuck with this deodorant for a month or two but I continued to sweat heavily and I could smell my sweat. It sucked! I thought I had developed some heavy sweating issues until I switched back to Dove and realized it was just this deodorant. My dove deodorant works great compared to the Secret deodorant. I definitely won't be using Secret again.

This deodorant seemed to work really well at first, but like most deodorants, the effect seemed to wear out over time. I live in SoCal where the weather is typically in the high 80s, and I found myself having to reapply towards the end of the day. Also, this deodorant leaves white marks often and seems to ball up and become very visible as you sweat. Unfortunately, I will not continue to use this deodorant.

I was sent 4 Ladies Speed Stick instead of 4 Secret Powder Fresh. I am not happy with this as I can only use Secret Powder Fresh.

I've used this product for years. It was the only one I could use and I was very pleased with the results. Recently, the product is not working the same way. I have an older one that works but the newer ones do not. What happened? Did the formula change? How can I get the old one back? P.S. The previous formula would've gotten 5 stars.

I have used the original solid since high school. The most recent stick I used has a different ingredient PPG-14 butyl ether and has given me a rash. Thankfully I have a few old sticks left, after that, I'm going to have to switch brands. The ingredients list on this page doesn't list this chemical. Why not?

So, although this website states that this is Secret's "original tried and trusted formula," Secret has actually changed the ingredients (and I should also note that they are different than what appears on this very website). I have used the Powder Fresh since I was in middle school - 30 years later, the formula has changed and I can no longer use it. The new formula has the following new ingredients: mineral oil, PPG-14 butyl ether, and petrolatum. The texture of the new product is less dry, and feels kind of like lotion under your arms (and not in a good way). By far, the worst change is the different fragrance. As others have mentioned, there used to be just a subtle baby powder smell - now it is overwhelming, cloying, and chemical-y. Procter & Gamble should really consider that people have allergies, and a such a huge change in formulation should be clearly noted on the bottle.