So far I've only used the Sweet Orange and the Cedarwood. Aside from the pucks being ridiculously small, there is no orange or citrus aroma in the Sweet Orange whatsoever. I'm racking my brain trying to identify the scent, but all I get is hints of…bubblegum?
The Cedarwood is pleasant, much more so than the Sweet Orange, but it is far from smelling like true cedar.
The price for what you receive is really not bad, but I had to use old tea cups to keep those tiny pucks from swirling around. I would have preferred thinner pucks of larger diameter, or increasing the weight. As it stands, it seems like “toy” shaving soap